Talk:Joseph Bonanno

Untitled
The dates in this article are inconsistant with those in Carmine Galante which links here, or else there are two people of the same name who are not being clearly distinguished. This should be corrected with accurate information. DES 16:33, 21 July 2005 (UTC)

This page is quite inaccurate. Harry Nieman, Nov. 3, 2005

Very,very inaccurate indeed. Ice Cold 18:21, 18 July 2006 (UTC)

Aside from inaccurate, needs MAJOR style work!
Parts of it read like a high-school student's sloppy research paper. This article definitely needs editing.Lawikitejana 05:33, 7 August 2006 (UTC)

Needs some work on the factual basis
Things I found: 1) Joe Bonanno disliked the nickname "Joe Bananas" because the reporter who coined it disrespected his name - nothing to do with an implication of his being "crazy" as far as I ever heard. Joe Bonanno was known to be very proud of his name.

2) There appear to be no references listed for subtopics/claims, e.g., Mussolini/Fascist regime.

3) A capo is NOT a boss! A capo is a captain.  The boss is highest up - then the underboss - consigliere - capo di tutti capi (captain of captains) - capos - soldiers.Tzittnan 19:15, 18 January 2007 (UTC)


 * ^He's right. Wakata —Preceding unsigned comment added by 76.171.47.243 (talk) 23:57, 25 December 2009 (UTC)

Castellamare del Golfo is not on the western coast of Sicily. It is in western Sicily, but is on the north coast. I've ridden the train through CdG several dozen times, and I know. 69.171.160.64 (talk) 12:53, 27 June 2011 (UTC)Brian A. Cobb, brianallancobb@hotmail.com

Inconsistent Dates
He couldn't be born in 1905 if in 1906, at the age of 26, he took his one year old son, and his wife to the United States. Also, after mentioning him being 26, later on in the article it throw off chronological ordering by mentioning something that happened when he was nineteen. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by Ziing (talk • contribs) 00:11, 26 January 2007 (UTC).

Movie Bonanno : Godfather's story
-Did you watched the movie Bonanno : Godfather's story? There is a lot of things they aren't wrote here. For example how Joseph Bonanno helped American Army in World War II contacting his friend on Sicily officialy Lucky Luciano did this job but in movie Luciano ask for the help Joe Bonanno. In this article We can find out that Joe Bonanno want Bill Bonanno to take over the family buisness in New York but in movie is nothing about that. In movie both Joe and Bill want to retired in Tucson. And the drug buisness Joe Bonanno disapprove the trafficking the drugs and prostitution but i find out from the diffrent sources but Bonanno family was the major drug supplier and i don't know for sure that Joe Bonanno was a drug dealer or not?? Maybe only Carmine Galante was a dealer after he took control of the family. I dont't know. And in the movie is nothing about Bonanno plot to kill his cousin, Carlo GAmbino and Thomas Lucchese. In movie is nothing about that. Maybe this plot wasn't true?? Anybody who interesting a little in organizaded crime and especially in italian Cosa Nostra should watch this movie. I like more than that of course Godfather and Once upon a time in America but this movies are fiction but Bonanno : Godfather's story is a real story of Godfather. Is one of better movies based on the true story. Of course is not class of Goodfellas or Casino but is really good. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 83.9.45.139 (talk) 20:08, 29 March 2007 (UTC).

I removed the word "suburban" in describing his house in Tucson. I live a few block's away (his house is in a very nice neighborhood, mine isn't) it is smack dab in the middle of Tucson. About a mile from the university. It definetly isn't suburban. It was sold a few years ago. malatesta 03:09, 5 May 2007 (UTC)

Not objectively written, poorly cited
I'm sorry but I found this article quite biased, with only one reference to Bonanno's autobiography -- and that basically calling him a liar -- and a number of contentions presented as fact with no documentation or references. Having just read "Man of Honor," I'll give an example. Bonanno claims he never went to the Appalachin meeting. He says one of his men was carrying a driver's license with his name on it because he was supposed to renew it for him, something one didn't have to do in person in New York at the time. Has anyone found a mugshot, fingerprints, or any other evidence that Bonanno was actually detained during the Appalachin fiasco? I don't think so, and so I find it dubious to present his "arrest" as fact. I'm sure Joe may have taken some liberties when writing his autobiography, but I actually find it credible that he did not involve himself in drugs or prostitution, as he was an old-school Sicilian, yet this article convicts him of both -- though, as the article admits, he was never convicted of any serious crime whatsoever.