Talk:Snorri Thorfinnsson

Untitled
It is possible that Snorri was a male..as, duing that time, females most usually had the ending -dottir..

Mother's name ?
The entry for Freydís Eiríksdóttir mentions her as a possible mother, but then also states that other sources claim Gudridr Thorbjörnsdottir. This article lists Guðríður Eiríksdóttir as the mother's name (which looks very much like a mixture of those two earlier names). Any references for any of these would be appreciated. ThreeBlindMice 22:31, 17 May 2006 (UTC)


 * I wrote a fairly detailed synopsis at Grœnlendinga saga and a quick glance at Eiríks saga rauða seems to agree that Guðríðr Þorbjarnardóttir was the mother. Haukur 22:36, 17 May 2006 (UTC)


 * And those are the only two detailed primary sources on the Norse exploration of North-America, if you read those two you're good. There are translations online but beware of the confusing nomenclature. Haukur 22:39, 17 May 2006 (UTC)


 * Thanks for the quick reply. Not being familiar with Icelanding names, can I take it that your reply means that the mother's name in this article should be changed to Gudridr Thorbjörnsdottir (I'm assuming that this is equivalent to ON:Guðríðr Þorbjarnardóttir)? If yes, then I take it that the entry for Freydís Eiríksdóttir should not make any reference to this article. I'm not asking you to make these changes, just whether that would be correct based on the information available. ThreeBlindMice 23:31, 17 May 2006 (UTC)

too much material about other unrelated stuff
fully half of this article is about others living over 500 years later -- a kind of useless rebuttal of the speculation that Snorri was the earliest euro birth. The whole section starting "The first documented" is irrelevant and should go. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 206.248.138.150 (talk) 03:26, 28 January 2007 (UTC).

Birth date
Islendingabok.is speculates that he was born around 1004, though I don't know how correct that may be.. The current article states that he was likely born between 1005 and 1013, and died c. 1090, so if no one minds, I'll just extend that range by one year. --MrGulli (talk) 12:22, 26 December 2009 (UTC)

"The celebarated sculptor, Thorvaldsen, was a descendant of this Snorri thorfinnsson, who was born in America, A.D.1008...Marthas Vineyard... Spontaniously growing wheat(maze or indian corn)"(Rudolph Keyser, religion of the northman 1854). note see "corn" King James Bible. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Americo Simoes (talk • contribs) 14:59, 30 December 2010 (UTC)


 * Since Snorri seems to have been accepted by Wiki in 2009 as the first European child born in continental America, Why is he not shown elsewhere in Wiki as the first European child born in America, c. 1005? Vince Koers, vincekoers@aol.com 2601:241:C202:F2B0:75AC:2937:1F3:FCF4 (talk) 13:37, 6 June 2022 (UTC)

Family Tree
The Family Tree diagram was installed in the 12:57, 21 July 2009 edit of the article by. I made a few corrections on the earlier ancestors thus:
 * Thord Thorbrandsson-> Thord Bjarnarson at Hofdi
 * Snorri Thordsson-> Thordarson
 * Thordar Snorrisson->Snorrason

I followed "Index of Characters" of the Viking anthology The Sagas of the Icelanders on the patronymics (see ref in the article for further details). Don't know who Thord Thorbrandsson might be, but it is probably related to Alarichus confusing Snorri Thordarson (the grandfather) with Snorri Thorbrandsson (who accompanied Thorfinn to Vinland) saying these were aliases of the same person (in this edit: 16:52, 20 July 2009.

I make a log of my edits, though I think the issue is closed. Unless of course, I've made my own errors. I intend to update the Family tree by adding the branch from "Snorri Karlsefnisson had another daugher called Steinunn, etc." as occurs in the Hauksbok version, Magnusson & Palsson tr. I've already created a family tree on Thorfinn Karlsefni page which goes into further detail on the ancestry, which I would like others to fact-check. --Kiyoweap (talk) 14:07, 23 March 2013 (UTC).

Snorri Thorfinnsson's birth year 1005 and 1013
The line in the article that reads:
 * There are various speculations about the birthdate of Snorri Thorfinnsson like 1005, 1009, 1012, but all agree that he was born between 1005 and 1013.

is poorly sourced. The footnote is bogus, since as far as I can tell, this book says that Thorfinn's party embarked in the spring of 1007, and Snorri was born that winter (i.e. 1007 or 1008). I have modified the citation on the Mallet book also. Harvard is not the publisher but the owner of a copy of the book used to this google edition. I saw his url supplied in a previous edit, but it had an extra "%C" tacked on at the end that render the link bad, and must have subsequently removed. Also, the book was orignially written in French by Mallet, but it was translated by Bishop Percy, with notes by I.A. Blackwell, and additional material (abstract of Eyrbyggja saga) by Walter Scott. The location being quoted out of was a "Supplementary chapter" not written by Mallet, but supplied by "the editors", hence, it is bad referencing to attribute it solely to "Mallet". Again, in a previous edit, someone had supplied the additional authors, but it has since been deleted or reverted. Sorry I'm not being particular about which edits on this.

Anyways, if the 1005-1013 dating wants to be kept it needs better sourcing. --Kiyoweap (talk) 14:19, 23 March 2013 (UTC)