Talk:Walther Gerlach

Nobel comittee
The opinions of the Nobel comittee in their consultations for the Nobel Prize for Stern (excluding Gerlach) ist cited with reference to an oral communication of Schmidt-Böcking, is this published anywhere ? When not its not a usable source.--Claude J (talk) 11:28, 19 December 2019 (UTC)

Stern-Gerlach priority
It looks like an editor only identified by their IP address has added their own strong opinion about Gerlach's priority for the Stern-Gerlach experiment to this article - including text where they explain their trouble with the Wikipedia system, and even personal remarks such as "permit me to add". From what I can see, that opinion is not backed up by secondary sources stating that opinion - what are cited are primary sources, in what amounts to WP:OR. I will clean that up now, keeping the cited sources, but removing what seems to be the OR assessment added by the anonymous editor. Markus Pössel (talk) 08:45, 9 October 2021 (UTC)
 * I have reformulated some of the text and removed the OR assertions of the anonymous editor intended to argue for Gerlach's sole priority for the Stern-Gerlach experiment. In particular, I have removed this paragraph, which I am preserving here so that if it turns up in a published reference somewhere, it or something like it could be re-inserted:
 * Otto Stern was among the nominees for the physics Nobel Prize in 1943 and was awarded the prize on 9 November 1944. The citation did not mention the highly important Stern-Gerlach experiment which Walther Gerlach finally carried out successfully early in 1922 during the Weimar Republic in the absence of Otto Stern who had already moved on to Rostock, thus withholding the honour from Gerlach in view of his continued activity in "Nazi-led" Germany at the end of the war. (Oral information from Prof. Dr. Horst Schmidt-Böcking, Institute for nuclear physics, Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe-Universität Frankfurt/Main in 2015, who conserves the unpublished documentation concerning the differing opinions within the Nobel-Committee on the subject of Walther Gerlach. Schmidt-Böcking is also engaged in the physical reassembling of Gerlach's experiment within the planned new Senckenberg-Museum at Frankfurt).
 * Markus Pössel (talk) 09:01, 9 October 2021 (UTC)