The Wrong Guy

The Wrong Guy is a 1997 Canadian black comedy film directed by David Steinberg, and starring Dave Foley, along with David Anthony Higgins, Jennifer Tilly, Colm Feore and Joe Flaherty. It was written by Foley, Higgins and Jay Kogen.

The script was inspired by a sketch Foley wrote during his days with The Kids in the Hall.

Synopsis
Dorky executive Nelson Hibbert (Foley) gets passed over for a promotion after spending years angling for the job (including an engagement to one of his boss's daughters). Upon hearing the decision, he ends up shouting "I swear I will kill you!" as security drags him from the board room. Later, when he goes to confront his boss (Kenneth Welsh), he finds that the man has already been murdered, and, due to the scene he made earlier, assumes that he will be mistaken for the murderer. Nelson flees, unaware that security cameras have already revealed the identity of the true killer to the authorities. Chaotic events transpire and What follows is a bizarre series of misadventures marked with slapstick routines and constant one-liners. Nelson tries to escape to Mexico, but along the way he frequently encounters both the real killer (Feore) and the police, causing the killer to mistake him for a government agent and make frequent attacks on his life. Nelson meets a narcoleptic farm girl named Lynn (Tilly) and falls in love with her, only for them both to end up as the killer's hostages. It turns out that Ken Daly, who got the promotion, had the company president killed in order to gain the spot quickly. Detective Arlen (Higgins) finally catches up with the killer and hostages, having halfheartedly pursued them while using the investigation as an excuse to spend police money on fancy dinners and broadway shows. The police capture the killer and Hibbert resolves to marry Lynn, having realized he must leave the rat race and live a simpler life, but he is instantly convinced by Lynn to return to Cleveland with her instead.

Cast
The members of Barenaked Ladies made cameos as singing policemen.

Release
Foley described The Wrong Guy as his best film.

The film was released direct-to-video in the United States through Hollywood Pictures.

Awards

 * Film Discovery Jury Award (U.S. Comedy Arts Festival) - Best Screenplay Dave Foley, David Anthony Higgins, Jay Kogen

Critical response
In 2023, Barry Hertz of The Globe and Mail named the film as one of the 23 best Canadian comedy films ever made.