User:Fritzmann2002/Notes/Samnites GAN


 * 1) Quality of Writing
 * 2) Clarity
 * 3) "In the Samnite's free time, Samnites often hunted. This was not the only kind of entertainment practiced by the Samnites."
 * 4) Spelling & Grammar
 * 5) Manual of Style
 * 6) Lead
 * 7) Layout
 * 8) Words to Watch
 * 9) Fiction
 * 10) List incorporation
 * 11) Verifiability
 * 12) Reflist style
 * 13) Reliability
 * 14) Original Research
 * 15) Copyvio
 * 16) Coverage
 * 17) Main aspects
 * 18) Focus
 * 19) Neutrality
 * 20) Stability
 * 21) Illustrations
 * 22) Tagging: Overall, the images are properly tagged and there is no copyvio on the article's part. Just a few small issues on the Commons end that need to be sorted out to ensure proper attribution and that all images are free use.
 * 23) "Loom weights with a fibula and a tweezers design.jpg" has an incorrect link to its source which needs to be corrected
 * 24) "Bronze Bull.png" has a very vague source, no link to where it was found, and questionable authorship which need to be addressed
 * 25) Relevancy
 * 26) The images improve the article greatly and are appropriate in almost all situations. However, I question the use of "Bronze Bull.png"; it is a very poor quality image and I have to believe there are better images on Commons which could better illustrate Samnite religion. Compounded with its tagging issues and the best option in my opinion is probably to find a replacement.
 * 27) Captions
 * 28) Most of the captions are good, but there are a few that I feel could be just a tad more specific; they don't give me as the reader a precise idea of what the image actually is. The ones that I might expand were "Oscan inscription", "Capua", "Colline Gates", "Samnite loom weight.", and "Samnite art".