User:Lalidz

Matisoff biography
If you find the tone of the sentence in question contentious please feel free to rewrite it. Perhaps you are right that mention of issues of ongoing academic debate is not appropriate for a biography. If so then the description of the 2003 book is limited to the mere mention of its publication. Currently that paragraph contains laudatory information which I think is taken from the back of the book. Equally inappropriate for a biography. Tibetologist (talk) 08:55, 18 September 2010 (UTC)