User:Leflyman

 A no-longer so short page about Wikipedian Leflyman

WP:WARN * RfA analysis * User reg * My edit count * Articles * AFD summary

Aloha. I've been registered since January 2004, although I made a number of anonymous edits going back to months earlier. Three-and-a-half years is probably long enough.

My motivation for editing has been sapped of late by the increasing activities of fanatical individuals, who are doggedly determined to insert their particular point-of-view into articles. Among the great faults of Wikipedia is its open-arm acceptance of those who are primarily self-interested in promoting their personal ideology, philosophy, resentment or prejudice. There are a limited number of those who write clearly, edit well and know how to differentiate between biased and neutral language -- while there are unlimited hoards of off-kilter bad writers, with apparently boundless time and enthusiasm to wear down even the most resolute of editors. Just as rational discussions are fruitless with unreasonable participants, the entropic effect of poor edits can not be fended off indefinitely. I would argue that for many articles, time and additional eyes has not improved their quality; and in many cases, the more recent are no better-- or even worse-- than those of past.

Take for example, one of the first articles I edited, Robot. Here is how the lede sentences stood on May 4, 2005: "In practical usage, a robot is a mechanical device which performs automated tasks, either according to direct human supervision, a pre-defined program or, a set of general guidelines, using artificial intelligence techniques. These tasks either replace or enhance human work, such as in manufacturing, construction or manipulation of heavy or hazardous materials."

A year later, on May 14, 2006, it read: "A robot is a mechanical device that can perform preprogrammed physical tasks. A robot may act under the direct control of a human (eg. the robotic arm of the space shuttle) or autonomously under the control of a pre-programmed computer. Robots may be used to perform tasks that are too dangerous or difficult for humans to implement directly (e.g. the space shuttle arm) or may be used to automate repetitive tasks that can be performed more cheaply by a robot than by the employment of a human (e.g. automobile production)."

Today, with another year of edits, it starts with: "A robot is a mechanical or virtual, artificial agent. A robot is usually an electro-mechanical system, which, by its appearance or movements, conveys a sense that it has intent or agency of its own."

Which of those is better? The latest version of the article has some virtues, but for the most part, its writing is inferior to the incarnation of two years ago. Like a chili recipe that becomes unpalatable as countless cooks keep adding ingredients to their own preferences, Wikipedia is doomed to a constant struggle of tastes -- and mischief.

As for myself, I've grown weary of trying to "fix" the various problems, unintentional or not, which seem to be growing, lockstep with the expansion of Wikipedia content.

So for now; I'm off.

Wiki-philosophy
What I believe...
 * I believe the task of a general encyclopedia is to be useful to the widest range of people, not merely technical specialists or detail-oriented fans. While I previously described myself as a subscriber to the Wikipedia philosophy of "Deletionism", I would term myself an adherent to "Significantism"-- which I consider to be a more accurate reflection of "notability", and a preferable term to "importance". My belief is that articles should demonstrate the significance of their subject matter. In regards to articles and additions of extremely limited significance, only by weeding can Wikipedia flourish into a true garden of knowledge (to extend a clichéd metaphor.) That's not to say that obscure topics do not deserve a place here, so long as their contents are neutral, verifiable and free of original research.

Major contributions
I've contributed to a wide range of articles-- from science and religion, to culture, history and entertainment-- although I prefer to keep watch over a few specific ones of interest, to ensure their quality remains stable, and to reverse Wiki-entropy. In particular, I have been a long-time editor of the constellation of Lost (TV series) articles, including (re)writing nearly every section of the main article, as well as many of the ancillary pages. I walked it through two peer reviews, and was responsible for seeing Lost receive Today's Featured Article for October 3.

Some other pages I've had a major hand in developing/revising (but didn't start):
 * Ben Stiller - Earliest edits from October 2003, later complete rewrites
 * Robot - First article edited after registration, and hacked apart
 * Pseudoreligion - Rewrite saved from deletion
 * Characters of Lost - Plus the various character bios
 * List of snowclones - Reorganised, redacted and established dates of origin
 * List of people from Tulsa, Oklahoma - Categorised, alphabetised
 * Lost: The Journey - Rewrote non-encyclopedic episode article into a verifiable, sourced one
 * PC Load Letter - Reorganised into encyclopedic article with sources
 * Jewish Life Network - Rewrite saved from deletion
 * Daniel Mendelsohn - Re-write to eliminate copyvioed text

Articles initiated
And some of the random articles I started, mostly dealing with entertainment or music:
 * Cluetrain - first stab at an article (8 February, 2004), merged into The Cluetrain Manifesto
 * Fran Rubel Kuzui -- Director of Buffy the Vampire Slayer (film) (10 Jan 2006)
 * Rollergirls -- Short-lived Bravo series (13 Jan 2006)
 * The Spot -- Early Web fiction series (16 Jan 2006)
 * Golden Driller -- Tulsa oil man sculpture (17 Jan 2006)
 * David Fury -- TV writer (19 Jan 2006)
 * Geronimo Black -- Rock band (24 Jan 2006)
 * Ars Mathematica -- Arts non-profit (31 Jan 2006)
 * Flying Blind -- Short-lived 90s Fox series(10 Feb 2006)
 * Jay Gorney -- Tin-pan Alley song writer (1 Mar 2006)
 * Alec Newman -- English Actor (1 Mar 2006)
 * Joe Ely -- Honkey tonk musician (1 Mar 2006)
 * Camden Toy -- Buffyverse Character actor (11 Mar 2006)
 * DHARMA Initiative stations -- Spin off from DHARMA Initiative (4 May 2006)
 * Annenberg Foundation -- Surprisingly missing (12 May 2006)
 * United States Chief of Protocol -- 2000th edit! (13 May 2006)
 * Philip Stark -- TV/screenwriter (23 June 2006)
 * List of crossovers on Lost -- Crufty, but necessary (15 July 2006)
 * List of references to Lost in popular culture -- Same deal (27 July 2006)
 * Amazon (TV series) -- Single-season syndicated series (30 September 2006)
 * Lost (1956 film) and Lost (2004 film) - Additional films with Lost titles (4 December 2006)
 * Chris William Martin -- Canadian actor (17 December 2006)
 * The Lost (book) -- Another in my series of "Lost" titles (29 December 2006)
 * Hamsin -- Oppressive dust storm of the Middle East (20 February 2007)