Wall of Eyes

Wall of Eyes is the second studio album by the English rock band the Smile, released on 26 January 2024 through XL Recordings. It was recorded in Oxford and Abbey Road Studios, London, with the producer Sam Petts-Davies.

The Smile developed the songs while on tour for their first album, A Light for Attracting Attention (2022). After releasing the single "Bending Hectic" in June 2023, the Smile announced the album with the single "Wall of Eyes" in November, followed by "Friend of a Friend" in January. Paul Thomas Anderson directed music videos for "Wall of Eyes" and "Friend of a Friend".

Wall of Eyes received acclaim and entered the top ten of several national albums charts. The Smile began a tour of Europe in March 2024.

Recording
The Smile are composed of the Radiohead members Jonny Greenwood and Thom Yorke with the drummer Tom Skinner. While on tour for their first album, A Light for Attracting Attention (2022), they performed many new songs, including several future Wall of Eyes tracks. 

Whereas most of Yorke's previous work, including the previous Smile album, was produced by Nigel Godrich, Wall of Eyes was produced and mixed by Sam Petts-Davies.  Petts-Davies previously produced Yorke's 2018 soundtrack ''Suspiria. ''

The Smile recorded Wall of Eyes in Oxford and Abbey Road Studios, London, with strings performed by the London Contemporary Orchestra. Yorke said that Abbey Road was the best studio in London, and lamented that it had a "touristy" element because of its association with the Beatles. In March 2023, the Smile confirmed that they were seven weeks into recording. In June, Greenwood said the album was about working within the limits of a three-person band, and that they were still working through a backlog of ideas generated during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Music and lyrics
The opening track, "Wall of Eyes", features strummed acoustic guitar, strings and a samba-like rhythm in 5/4 time. Stereogum described it as "light, lilting, insular" and "soft and graceful, with a growing sense of unease and discordance". "Teleharmonic" combines "celestial vocals, soulful bass, rippling synth, and tumbling drums". "Read the Room", a "math-rock odyssey", features a motorik drum beat. "Under our Pillows" culminates in an ambient drone. Stereogum likened the piano song "Friend of a Friend" to the work of Randy Newman and Ben Folds, and likened the strings to the 1967 Beatles song "A Day in the Life". "Bending Hectic" begins with a detuned guitar and builds to a crescendo, with lyrics describing a car crash, a familiar subject for Yorke.

The download for the 2009 Radiohead song "These Are My Twisted Words" contained a text file containing the phrase "Wall of Ice", triggering speculation that it was the title of an upcoming Radiohead EP. The phrase "wall of eyes" later appeared in promotional materials for Radiohead's 2011 album ''The King of Limbs.  Responding to suggestions that the Wall of Eyes'' lyrics indicated that Radiohead had broken up, Greenwood said: "No, we would never write songs about ourselves, like that. There's a lot of history of bands doing it, and it just makes you shiver with embarrassment sometimes when you read those lyrics."

Release
The Smile contributed a version of "Teleharmonic" to a 2022 episode of the television drama Peaky Blinders. The first Wall of Eyes single, "Bending Hectic", was released on 20 June 2023. Wall of Eyes was announced on November 13 2023, alongside the second single, "Wall of Eyes". The "Wall of Eyes" music video was directed by Paul Thomas Anderson and filmed at the Mildmay Club in London in October 2023. It has Yorke wandering through London, drinking alone in a pub, staring at a wall of eyeballs and sitting among dozens of versions of himself. The third single, "Friend of a Friend", was released on 9 January 2024.

From 19 January, the Smile held a series of screenings at independent cinemas around the world, titled Wall of Eyes, on Film. The events included listening parties for the album in surround sound, including an additional orchestral track, "Tiptoe"; footage from the album recording sessions; the premiere of Anderson's video for "Friend of a Friend"; and screenings of Anderson's previous videos with the Smile, Yorke and Radiohead. The band members made a surprise appearance at the Prince Charles Cinema in London and answered questions from the audience.

Wall of Eyes was released on 26 January 2024. It was the UK's highest-selling vinyl in the week of its release. The Smile began a European tour in March, including a performance at 6 Music Festival in Manchester with the London Contemporary Orchestra. Their August tour was canceled after Greenwood was temporarily hospitalised with a serious infection.

Critical reception
According to the review aggregator Metacritic, Wall of Eyes received "universal acclaim". In Stereogum, Chris Deville wrote that it was "less explosive" than A Light For Attracting Attention, and "stands out for the way its songs resemble the outgrowth of a living organism rather than compositions pieced together". He described the Smile as a "fun phase" for Yorke and Greenwood, but expressed hope for a return for Radiohead and said the Smile demonstrated what the other Radiohead members contribute.

The Irish Times wrote that "Yorke and Greenwood have delivered yet another classic", and that Wall of Eyes had a "remarkable, sombre majesty" reminiscent of the 2016 Radiohead album A Moon Shaped Pool. The Guardian chief music critic, Alexis Petridis, chose Wall of Eyes as his album of the week, writing that it was "imaginative and viscerally thrilling, one of the best things Yorke and Greenwood have put their names to in at least a decade".

In Pitchfork, Jazz Monroe named Wall of Eyes the week's "best new music", writing that Yorke and Greenwood sounded more relaxed and had allowed their songwriting to absorb more influences. Consequence picked "Wall of Eyes" as their song of the week, describing it as "dizzyingly danceable and easily enjoyable ... the sound of three boundless musicians with enough ideas to span several lifetimes".

Personnel
Credits adapted from album liner notes.

The Smile
 * Jonny Greenwood – guitars, bass, piano, synthesisers, orchestral arrangements, cello, Max MSP
 * Tom Skinner – drums, synthesisers, percussion
 * Thom Yorke – voice, guitars, bass, piano, synthesisers, lyrics

Production
 * Sam Petts-Davies – production, engineering, mixing
 * Oli Middleton – engineering
 * Tom Bailey – orchestral engineering
 * Pete Clements – studio tech
 * Joe Wyatt – Abbey Road recording, assistant engineering
 * Tom Ashpitel – Abbey Road recording
 * Greg Calbi – mastering

Additional musicians
 * London Contemporary Orchestra, led by Eloisa-Fleur Thom
 * Hugh Brunt – conducting
 * Robert Stillman – clarinet, saxophone
 * Pete Wareham – flute