Wikipedia:Manual of Style/France- and French-related articles

The purpose of this supplementary manual is to create guidelines for editing articles in the English-language Wikipedia which relate to France or the French language to conform to a neutral encyclopedic style and to make things easy to read by following a consistent format. The following rules do not claim to be the last word. One way is often as good as another, but if everyone does it the same way, Wikipedia will be easier to read and use, not to mention easier to write and edit. This manual is open to all proposals, discussion, and editing.

There is considerable disagreement between the editors of articles related to France or French about which sources are reliable. The important thing to remember is that all sources and articles must conform to Wikipedia policies such as No original research, Verifiability and Neutral point of view.

General rules
The most general rule of the Wikipedia is that editors should use the most common form of the name or expression used in English (WP:ENGLISH). There are however many cases in which this rule is difficult to put into practice. When giving a parenthetical French expression after an English word, editors may use word where "word" is the French word. Example: National Assembly (Assemblée nationale).

If required in running text, French words or phrases should use lang, thus: Assemblée nationale, which renders as Assemblée nationale. This automatically produces italic rendering in accordance with MOS:FOREIGNITALIC.

Accents and ligatures
French proper names and expressions should respect the use of accents and ligatures in French. These are: Common French usage is to omit accents in capitals, however this is not the proper usage and accents should be included in capitals (as required by the Imprimerie nationale and usual in Canada). When used in article names, all common non-accented/non-ligatured forms should redirect to the article. There will often be many redirects, but this is intentional and does not represent a problem: Saint-Étienne, Édouard Manet, Édith Piaf, Émile Zola.

Sorting
Accented characters and ligatures should not affect the sort order of articles in categories etc. So, where proper names have accents or ligatures, include the  magic word in the article, with those accented characters and ligatures replaced by plain versions. See Évisa (source) for an example.

Note that communes and other places starting with the definite article (La, Le, Les, L') should have the  magic word added with the article absent, e.g. La Vernelle should contain.
 * Communes starting with the definite article

Apart from the above rules, the following conventions should also be followed:
 * Manual sorting within lists, templates etc.
 * Do not add the  magic word with hyphens missing


 * Communes starting with Saint- are always sorted before communes starting with Sainte-. Do not try to sort Sainte-* communes in with Saint-E* communes.

Capitalization
There have been two accepted methods to determine the capitalization of titles of works of art. The second method had been allowed (not required) only for operas and visual arts, but is in need of a new consensus evaluation.


 * Imprimerie nationale / Académie française method : These are the rules used on the French Wikipedia, which are those used by the French National publishing house (l'Imprimerie nationale) and put forth in its Lexique des règles typographiques en usage à l'Imprimerie nationale. This system is also favoured by the Académie française.  Titles which adhere to these rules may, however, differ from the form of capitalization originally adopted by the author, the cover's graphic artist, or the publishing house (especially for older works that pre-date the current advice of French language authorities).
 * These rules are as follows:
 * The words capitalized in titles of works of art (books, paintings, etc.) are:
 * proper nouns (names, cities)
 * the initial word of the title and:
 * if this initial word is a definite article (le, la, les, l'), both the article and its noun (and any modifier between the article and the noun) are capitalized (e.g. Le Grand Meaulnes; La Grande Illusion)
 * if the initial word is a modifier followed by a noun, the entire noun phrase is likewise capitalized (e.g. Tristes Tropiques)
 * However:
 * if the title is a sentence, only the first letter and proper nouns are capitalized (e.g. La vie est un long fleuve tranquille)
 * if the title contains an enumeration (e.g. La Belle et la Bête), subsequent nouns of that enumeration are capitalized
 * in cases of a double title (e.g. Émile ou De l'éducation), both parts of the title are treated individually by the above rules; explicit subtitles are likewise treated as complete titles.
 * Examples:
 * La Peau de chagrin (not "La peau de chagrin" or "La Peau de Chagrin")
 * L'Œuvre
 * Le Ventre de Paris
 * Les Misérables


 * Chicago Manual of Style (sentence case) method: Since at least the 14th ed. (1993, p. 320) The Chicago Manual of Style (CMoS) recommended only "capitalizing the first word of the title and of the subtitle and of all proper nouns". However, the 17th ed. (2017, §1127) now explicitly also recognizes the above system (citing the Académie française), and draws from it exceptions (like Le Monde) that it applies to its own sentence-case system. CMoS no longer recommends one system over the other, only using a single approach consistently.  In Wikipedia's early days, the CMoS sentence-case system was also followed by some major English-language reference works, for instance then-recent editions of New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, New Grove Dictionary of Opera, The Oxford Dictionary of Opera, and The Viking Opera Guide. However, new editions of such works have not been checked in this regard in over a decade.
 * Examples of the sentence-case approach: Les mamelles de Tirésias, Les Indes galantes, Les contes d'Hoffmann, La vie parisienne, La bohème.

Noble titles
There is currently no standard convention for French noble titles and present-day English usage varies greatly. In Wikipedia articles, French noble titles are currently listed in two different ways:
 * in English translation (Duke of, Count of...) for historical figures and royalty most well known by their English forms.
 * while present-day English usage varies with regards to the capitalization of these titles, editors should follow the Manual of Style/Capital letters.
 * while present-day English usage also varies with regards to the use of "of" or "de" after the titles, the consensus on Naming conventions (royalty and nobility) has been to use "of" when the English title is given.
 * in French for other cases, maintaining the French title spelling (seigneur, chevalier, marquis, duc, comte) and the de.

Furthermore, in the second case—French titles in French form—capitalization is currently chaotic:
 * in French with lowercase spelling: comtesse de, marquis de... (e.g., Marie de Rabutin-Chantal, marquise de Sévigné; Catherine de Vivonne, marquise de Rambouillet; Pierre de Bourdeille, seigneur de Brantôme; François Hédelin, abbé d'Aubignac; Jean François Paul de Gondi, cardinal de Retz).  This is considered correct usage in contemporary French, and is the form used by The Chicago Manual of Style and in article titles on the French wiki.
 * in French with capital spelling: Comtesse de, Marquis de... (e.g., Anne Robert Jacques Turgot, Baron de Laune; Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon; Adam Philippe, Comte de Custine). While capitalization of noble titles occurred historically in French, this usage is no longer correct in French.  This form is, however, frequently found in English.

Present English usage itself varies on how to spell such French forms and there is currently no consensus among editors on the issue of capitalization. As a general rule, if the individual is not better known by an English equivalent and a French form is to be used, it is recommended, regardless of which form of capitalization is used, that forms remain consistent throughout a specific article and that redirects be made from the other acceptable forms.

Creative works

 * Use English title when well-known : In Wikipedia articles and article titles, French titles of creative works should be put into English, if the work is well known by its title in English (with redirects from the French title). Examples: The Tales of Hoffmann, an opera by Offenbach; The Marriage of Figaro, a play by Beaumarchais; Sunflowers, a painting by van Gogh. If the work is better known by its title in French, then French should be maintained (with redirects from the English title).


 * Capitalization (see above ) : Usage varies in contemporary French with regards to the capitalization of words in titles, and especially to the capitalization of initial words after a definite article. All common forms with variant capitalization should redirect to the article. There will often be many redirects, but this is intentional and does not represent a problem.

Names of organizations and institutions
Subject to Manual of Style/Trademarks and Naming conventions (companies), names of organizations and institutions (e.g. orchestras, musical ensembles and groups, concert halls, festivals, schools, etc.) should follow official usage (i.e. the spelling, punctuation, etc. used by the organization's own publications – always check whether the organization has English-language publications, and if so what name is used in these). In the case of non-English names, we use official English versions if and when they have been established by the organization itself. If not, we use the native name. Original English names, translated from other languages, should not be created.

Cities and communes
Where possible, articles on cities and communes in France should go under placename. Where disambiguation is needed, articles have traditionally used the "comma convention" (the standard convention for place names on the English language Wikipedia) and been placed under placename, département. Thus Tours, but Duras, Lot-et-Garonne and Montreuil, Seine-Saint-Denis.

Note that on the French Wikipedia, disambiguation is done with the "parentheses convention" and cities appear as placename (département x). There is currently much discussion (see the talk page) for replacing the comma convention with a parentheses convention.

Arrondissements
'''Note that this section is still under discussion on the talk page: consensus may not have been reached and article titles and text will not all use this style. Please contribute to the discussion there.'''

Numbered municipal arrondissements (for example those of Paris), should use Arabic numbers and English ordinality suffixes, not the French system of Roman numerals and French suffixes. The city name should follow. For example, 5th arrondissement of Paris, not Paris, Ve arrondissement

French administrative terms
The French administrative terms département and région should not be used, except parenthetically in cases of ambiguity. Instead, the English-language terms "department" and "region" should be used.

The English-language terms urban area and metropolitan area are inexact equivalents for the French terms aire urbaine and unité urbaine. Piped links to the French terms should be used.

Rail (SNCF – RFF)
stub: France-rail-transport-stub

Multiple train units

 * name: SNCF Class NAME
 * category:
 * template: SNCF units
 * example: SNCF Class B 81500

Locomotives

 * name: SNCF Class NAME
 * category:
 * template: SNCF locos
 * example: SNCF Class BB 22200 though mediocre

Railways
Should the railway be a touristic railway, use the name used commercially (ex. Lézarde Express Régionale). If it is owned by the RFF, use the basis "Xxx–Yyy railway", with an en dash. (ex. Paris–Marseille railway). When deciding which end to put first, use the biggest end, or if they are both equally significant (or insignificant), just use what sounds right.

You should also use WP:TRAIL, and can base the diagram on the site Rail 21. Also, add a link to its regional "TER REGION" and "List of railway lines in France" and the Categories: Railway lines in France and REGION.

Stations

 * 1) Some stations are known by established common names. These are: Gare d'Austerlitz, Gare de Bercy, Gare de l'Est, Gare de Lyon, Gare Montparnasse. Gare du Nord, Gare Saint-Lazare, Gare de la Bastille, Gare d'Orsay, Charles de Gaulle–Étoile, Châtelet–Les Halles
 * 2) Other station articles should be titled "xxxx station". Where disambiguation is necessary, a suffix can be added e.g. to distinguish Luxembourg station (in Luxembourg City) from Luxembourg station (Paris)
 * 3) Where a station serves two communities, the two should be separated by an unspaced endash (e.g. Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines–Montigny-le-Bretonneux station or Mitry–Claye station
 * 4) Where a station is one of several serving a city, the qualifier should be preceded by an unspaced hyphen (e.g. Versailles-Rive Droite station, Versailles-Chantiers station.

The station's article should include a link to "List of SNCF stations in REGION" (see List of SNCF stations) and the Category: "Railway stations in REGION".

Tram

 * All articles about tramways should go under the title "CITY tramway". You should also add the template France Rapid transit and the categories,  and  . Most pages will have a French equivalent, so link to it (it can be found at fr:Liste des tramways en France)

French names in Canada-related articles
French names in articles pertaining to subjects related to Quebec, Acadia, and the rest of Canada should follow the guideline set out at WP:CANSTYLE.