Wikipedia:Peer review/Cornell University/archive4

Cornell University
This peer review discussion has been closed. I've listed this article for peer review because…a user has asked for assistance in preparing this article for GA/FA.GrapedApe (talk) 18:05, 2 October 2010 (UTC)
 * Previous peer review

Images
 * GrapedApe's review
 * There are a number of problematic images that were uploaded from www.asergeev.com, but there does not appear to be adequate permission for some. I have asked for help from the OTRS team at commons commons:Commons:OTRS/Noticeboard.
 * File:CentralAvenueCornell2.jpg appears to be OK. File:Cornell War Memorial.jpgFile:SageHallsideview2.jpgFile:Cornell West campus dormitories.jpgFile:PictureofMyronTaylorHall.jpg - these have questionable copyright status.
 * After checking with the OTRS team, these images are OK. (See Commons:Template:Alex Sergeev permission).--GrapedApe (talk) 01:07, 11 October 2010 (UTC)


 * The image from www.biocrawler.com (File:Biocrawler.Cornell Law School 2.jpg) doesn't appear to have enough evidence to support its license.
 * There are a number of images uploaded by User:Cornell010 that I have some concerns about. Usually when you see web-resolution images with high quality photographic quality w/o EXIF data, that raises red flags.
 * File:Sage Chapel interior 2008.jpgFile:Cornell med 02.jpgFile:Bhangra.JPG


 * There are some images that could use some photographic restoration/editing
 * File:Cornell1902Panorama.jpg - could use some cleanup: remove the border, crease lines, and the handwriting in the center.
 * File:Dragon Day 1901.JPG - remove border


 * File:Skorton Speech.jpg isn't properly licensed from flickr: cc-by-nc-nd isn't a free license.
 * I'd like to know when the sculpture depicted in File:Jennie McGraw sarcophagus, Sage Chapel, Cornell Univ Ithaca NY.jpg was created. I'm concerned about it being a derivative work of a sculpture. (See commons:Commons:Derivative works for an explanation).
 * Presumably in the 1880's as the woman buried in the sarcophagus died in 1881. --Xtreambar (talk) 16:16, 3 October 2010 (UTC)