Zaynab bint Ali

Zaynab bint Ali (زَيْنَب بِنْت عَلِيّ, c. 626682), was the eldest daughter of Fatima and Ali ibn Abi Talib. The former was a daughter of the Islamic prophet Muhammad, and the latter was his cousin. Ali is also recognized as the fourth Rashidun caliph ((r. 656 – 661)) and the first Shia imam. Zaynab is best known for her role in the aftermath of the Battle of Karbala (680 CE), in which her brother Husayn and most of her male relatives were massacred by the forces of the Umayyad caliph Yazid ibn Mua'awiya ((r. 680 – 683)). Women and children in Husayn's camp were taken captive after the battle and marched to Kufa and then the Umayyad capital Damascus, where Zaynab gave impassioned speeches, condemning Yazid and spreading the news of Karbala. She was later freed and died shortly afterward in 682, but her burial site is uncertain. The two shrines associated with Zaynab in Damascus and Cairo are destinations for Muslim pilgrimage. She is considered to be a symbol of sacrifice, strength, and piety in Islam, and a role model for Muslim women, typifying courage, leadership, and defiance against oppression.

Titles
The Arabic word literally means 'adornment of father'. She is also known as Zaynab al-Kubra (lit. 'the senior Zaynab') to distinguish her from her younger sister Umm Kulthum or Zaynab al-Sughra (lit. 'the junior Zaynab'). Another title of Zaynab is Aqilatu Bani Hashim (lit. 'the sage of the Bani Hashim'), where the word literally means 'the secluded one' or 'pearl'. She is also recognized as Batalatu al-Karbala (lit. 'the heroine of Karbala') for her role in that event. Sometimes she is referred to as al-Sayyida (lit. 'the lady'), and in Egypt as al-Tahira (lit. 'the pure one') and Umm al-Yatama (lit. 'mother of the orphans').

Birth and early life
Zaynab was the third child of Fatima and Ali ibn Abi Talib, and their eldest daughter. The former was the daughter of the Islamic prophet Muhammad, and the latter was his cousin. Ali is also recognized as the fourth Rashidun caliph ((r. 656 – 661)) and the first Shia imam. There is not much clarity about Zaynab's early life, and even the year of her birth is given variously by different sources as 46 AH (6268 CE), or 9 (631). Shia Muslims celebrate her birthday annually on 5 Jumada al-Awwal. Her name was chosen by her grandfather Muhammad, who attributed the name to divine inspiration. When she was born, the angel Gabriel is said to have forewarned Muhammad about her difficult life. Muhammad was very fond of his granddaughter, reputedly saying that she resembled his late wife Khadija. Shia sources also emphasize the intense devotion of the young Zaynab to her brother Husayn. Unlike her parents and her two brothers, namely, Hasan and Husayn, Zaynab is not among the Fourteen Infallibles in Twelver Shi'ism. As she was raised with and by infallibles, she is nevertheless believed to have had "minor infallibility" in Twelver Shi'ism.

As a young child, Zaynab might have foreseen her future trials: She is said to have seen in a dream that she was caught in a large tree amidst a storm. When the tree was uprooted by the strong winds, she grasped for branches and twigs, which also broke one after another, and she woke us as she began to fall. Muhammad told her that the tree, the branches, and the twigs represented her grandfather, parents, and brothers, respectively, who would all die before her.

Death of Muhammad and Fatima (632)
Muhammad died in 632 and Zaynab thus lost her grandfather at an early age. As Muhammad's family prepared for the burial, a group of Muslims gathered at the Saqifa and appointed as his successor Abu Bakr, a senior companion. They did so in the absence of Muhammad's family and the majority of the Muhajirun (Meccan Muslims). Ali, Fatima, and some supporters did not recognize the caliphate of Abu Bakr, claiming that Muhammad had appointed Ali as his successor, referring to the Ghadir Khumm shortly before his death. Soon after the Saqifa affair, Umar, another companion of Muhammad, is known to have led an armed mob to Ali's residence and threatened to set the house on fire if Ali and his supporters did not pledge their allegiance to Abu Bakr. The confrontation then grew violent, but the mob retreated without securing Ali's pledge.

Fatima died in the same year, within six months of Muhammad's death, and at the age of about eighteen or twenty-seven. Shia Islam asserts that she miscarried her child and died from the injuries she suffered in an attack on her house, intended to subdue Ali, instigated by Abu Bakr and led by his aide Umar. These claims are rejected by Sunni Muslims, who believe that Fatima died from grief after the death of Muhammad and that her child died in infancy of natural causes. Zaynab thus lost her mother at the age of about five. According to the Sunni author A. Abd al-Rahman, Fatima on her deathbed entrusted Zaynab with a white garment for Husayn to wear as his shroud when leaving for the battlefield in Karbala.

Marriage and family life


Zaynab married her paternal cousin Abd Allah, whose father Ja'far al-Tayyar ibn Abi Talib was Muhammad's cousin and a prominent early Muslim, who was killed in the Battle of Mu'ta (629) against the Byzantines. Abd Allah was a narrator of prophetic hadiths, thirteen of which appear in the canonical Sunni collection. Abd Allah also narrated hadiths from the Shia imams and might have lived long enough to be a companion to the Shia imam Muhammad al-Baqir, although this last claim is not reported by the prominent Shia scholar Shaykh Tusi. Abd Allah was wealthy and known for his generosity, even though he is said to have lived modestly. Accordingly, the marriage ceremony of Zaynab and Abd Allah is described as a simple affair. The Shia author M. Eshtehardi writes that Zaynab married Abd Allah on the condition that she would be allowed to daily visit her brother Husayn and travel with him.

The couple had four sons, named Ali, Awn, Abbas, and Muhammad. They also had a daughter named Umm Kulthum. The Islamicist J. Esposito differs here, as he suggests that the couple had three sons and two daughters, without naming them. Awn and Muhammad were killed in the Battle of Karbala, and there is no information about Abbas, but Zaynab's lineage continued through Ali, also known as Ali al-Zaynabi.

Religious learning and eloquence
For her knowledge of prophetic hadiths, Muhammad's prominent cousin Ibn Abbas referred to Zaynab as Aqilatu Bani Hashim (lit. 'the sage of the Bani Hashim'). Her reputation among hadith scholars was apparently such that they cited Ali as the 'father of Zaynab' during the Umayyad's ban on publicly speaking about Ali. She also taught Quranic exegesis to women in her hometown of Medina, and later in Kufa, and was likely trained in this subject by her father Ali, whom the Islamicist T. Qutbuddin praises as "the most learned of [Islamic] sages."

Zaynab is described as eloquent, reputedly reminding her listeners of her father Ali. A sermon attributed to Zaynab after the Battle of Karbala is recorded by the Muslim historian Ibn Abi Tahir Tayfur in his, which is an anthology of eloquent speeches by women. The book also contains another sermon, which the author attributes to Zaynab's sister Umm Kulthum. Nevertheless, this second speech has also been attributed to Zaynab by most later authors, including the Shia scholar Ibn A'tham. Qutbuddin considers this latter attribution a strong possibility.

Death of Ali (661)
Ali was elected caliph in 656, after which he established himself in Kufa as his de facto capital in 656657. Zaynab and Abd Allah accompanied Ali to Kufa. There he was assassinated during the morning prayer at the Mosque of Kufa in January 661, which coincided with Ramadan, the month of fasting in Islam. The biographical, authored by the prominent Shia scholar al-Mufid , details that Ali spent his last night as Zaynab's guest for Iftar and Suhur, and that the wounded Ali was brought back to her house after the attack. Soon after Ali's death, his eldest son Hasan was elected caliph in Kufa, but later abdicated in favor of Mu'awiya ((r. 661 – 680)) in August 661, possibly due to the latter's overwhelming military superiority and the weak support of the Iraqis for war. The peace treaty between Hasan and Mu'awiya stipulated that the latter should not appoint a successor.

Death of Hasan (669)
Hasan returned to Medina after his abdication, accompanied by his family, where he kept aloof from politics in compliance with the peace treaty with Mu'awiya. Early sources are nearly unanimous that Hasan was later poisoned at the instigation of Mu'awiya in 669, possibly to pave the way for the succession of his son Yazid ((r. 680 – 683)). Zaynab is said to have attended her brother Hasan in his final days. Hasan was thus succeeded as the head of Muhammad's family by his brother Husayn, who nevertheless upheld the treaty with Mu'awiya.

Accession of Yazid (680)
Mu'awiya designated his son Yazid as his successor in 676, violating his earlier agreement with Hasan. Yazid is often remembered by Muslim historians as a debaucher who openly violated the Islamic norms, and his nomination was met with resistance from the sons of Muhammad's prominent companions, including Husayn ibn Ali. On Mu'awiya's death and Yazid's succession in 680, the latter instructed the governor of Medina to secure Husayn's pledge of allegiance by force. Husayn thus left Medina for Mecca at night to avoid recognizing Yazid as the caliph. He was accompanied by some relatives, including Zaynab and two of her sons, namely, Awn and Muhammad.

Zaynab's husband Abd Allah did not accompany Husayn even though he was sympathetic to Husayn's cause, according to the Sunni historian al-Tabari. Eshtehardi suggests that Abd Allah's absence must have been due to his poor health or old age and that sending his sons with Husayn was an indication of his support. In contrast, Abd al-Rahman writes that Zaynab must have divorced Abd Allah before leaving Medina and that he later married Zaynab's sister Umm Kulthum, although her views have been criticized by some. As the husband's permission is necessary in such cases under Islamic laws, some have instead suggested that a condition of her marriage to Abd Allah was that Zaynab could accompany Husayn in all his travels, or specifically to Karbala.

Journey towards Karbala
After receiving letters of support from some Kufans, whose intentions were confirmed by his cousin Muslim ibn Aqil, Husayn left Mecca for Kufa on 10 or 12 September 680, accompanied by some relatives and supporters. A tradition attributed to Husayn in describes his goal as fighting the tyranny of Yazid, even though it would cost his life. Husayn similarly wrote in his will for his half-brother Ibn Hanafiyya that he had not set out to seek "corruption or oppression" but rather to "enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong." At any rate, on their way to Kufa, Husayn's small caravan was intercepted by Yazid's army and forced to camp in the desert land of Karbala on 2 Muharram 61 (2 October 680) away from water and fortifications. The promised Kufan support did not materialize as the new governor of Kufa, Ubayd Allah ibn Ziyad, killed the envoy of Husayn and intimidated Kufan tribal chiefs.

Water shortage
On 7 Muharram, acting on orders of Ibn Ziyad, the Umayyad commander Umar ibn Sa'd cut off Husayn's access to the Euphrates river. Husayn's half-brother Abbas ibn Ali and his men were nonetheless able to bring back some water to Husayn's camp in a night sortie. Despite this attempt, Husayn's camp suffered from thirst and hunger during the siege. Karbala has a hot desert climate.

Negotiations
Ibn Sa'd was instructed by Ibn Ziyad not to let Husayn leave unless he pledged his allegiance to Yazid. Husayn did not submit to Yazid, but negotiated with Ibn Ziyad through Ibn Sa'd to be allowed to retreat and avoid bloodshed. The governor did not relent, however, and finally ordered Ibn Sa'd to fight, kill, and disfigure Husayn and his supporters unless they pledged allegiance to Yazid, in which case their fate would be decided later.

Tasu'a (9 Muharram)
At the request of Husayn, the confrontation was delayed on Tasu'a until the following day. Husayn then besieged his followers in a speech to leave him and not risk their lives, but nearly all those present stayed with him until the end. Husayn and his companions spent that night praying and reading the Quran, as reported by most works. On this night, Husayn revived and consoled Zaynab who had fainted in despair from the prospect of his imminent death. According to a common Karbala narrative, Zaynab also reminded her half-brother Abbas of their father's wish for the latter to be the reserves of Karbala, and to be to Husayn as Ali was to Muhammad. This Abbas confirmed and swore to do.

Ashura (10 Muharram)


On the morning of Ashura, Husayn organized his supporters, some seventy-two men, and then spoke to the enemy lines and asked them why they considered it lawful to kill Muhammad's grandson. The Umayyad commander al-Hurr ibn Yazid al-Tamimi defected to Husayn's side, probably after this speech. The Umayyad army then showered the camp with arrows, thus commencing the battle which lasted from morning till sunset and consisted of incidents of single combat, skirmishes, assaults, and retreats. The army also set Husayn's tents on fire, although al-Tabari believes that the tent of Husayn's wives (and children) was spared, adding that the Umayyad commander Shamir ibn Dhi al-Jawshan was dissuaded by other soldiers from setting that tent aflame.

Companions of Husayn all perished by the early afternoon and were followed by the Banu Hashim, including two sons of Husayn, three sons of Hasan, and the two sons of Zaynab present at Karbala, whom she is said to have encouraged to fight. In Shia view, Zaynab's motive in sacrificing her children was the survival of (Shia) Islam, even more so than her love for Husayn. Zaynab also consoled the families of the fallen warriors throughout the day, and cared for the wounded. She is said to have witnessed the battle from a platform made of saddles, but have remained in her tent when it was the turn of her sons to fight. By one account, she once rushed to the battlefield to help but was called back by Husayn who instructed her to care for those left behind. Similarly, al-Tabari reports that Zaynab ran to the battlefield crying and threw herself on her fallen nephew Ali al-Akbar ibn Husayn when the latter was killed in the fight. Husayn walked her back to the camp.

Death of Husayn
When Husayn's last remaining warrior fell, the Umayyad army converged on the lone imam, who nevertheless fought until the end. Before he left for the battlefield one last time, a common Karbala narrative holds that Zaynab kissed Husayn on behalf of their mother Fatima to fulfill her wish, and that Husayn asked Zaynab not to lament after his imminent death. When the wounded Husayn finally fell from his horse and was surrounded, Zaynab is said to have run towards him, beseeching Ibn Sa'd to spare her brother's life. The Umayyad commander ignored her request.

Husayn's family thus witnessed as he was repeatedly stabbed and slashed by the Umayyad soldiers. He was then decapitated by Shamir or Sinan ibn Anas, or by Khawali ibn Yazid Asbahi, although common accounts of Karbala hold Shamir responsible for this. Some accounts add that Zaynab had already returned to the camp, urged by the dying Husayn, and did not witness the beheading of her brother, but al-Tabari differs here. Modern Karbala narratives emphasize that Zaynab did not break down as she witnessed the murder of her brother, following Husayn's earlier wishes. Standing over Husayn's body, she reputedly uttered, "O God! Accept from us this offering," to the bewilderment of the enemy soldiers.

Immediate aftermath
After the death of Husayn, Umayyad soldiers stole his garments and personal belongings, pillaged his camp, and severed the heads of his fallen companions, which they then raised on spears for display. There are also reports of children's deaths during the Umayyad stampede. Acting upon earlier orders of Ibn Ziyad, the body of Husayn was then trampled, apparently by ten horsemen who volunteered to "inflict this final indignity" upon him. Some seventy-two bodies of Husayn and his companions were later buried by the Banu Asad men of the nearby al-Ghadiriyya village. The women and children were taken captive, including Zaynab and Umm Kulthum. Among the captives was also Husayn's only surviving son Ali, who had been too ill to fight. Known in Shia Islam by the honorific titles al-Sajjad and Zayn al-Abidin, Ali ibn al-Husayn was later recognized as the fourth of the Twelve Imams. It was through him that the line of Shia imams continued. Shamir attempted to kill Ali too, but Zaynab successfully pleaded to him to spare his life, saying that she had to be killed first. The captives mourned Husayn shortly after the battle.

Captives in Kufa
The captives were marched back to Kufa, arriving there on 12 Muharram. There are reports that the women were dishonored and ogled along the way, and that the captives were humiliated, carried on unsaddled camels, and, according to al-Tabari, bound in ropes and shackles. The captives were then paraded in shackles and unveiled around the city alongside the heads of Husayn and his companions on spears. The captives likely regarded Zaynab as their leader.

Zaynab's speech in Kufa
Ibn Tayfur records two speeches about Karbala in his, one attributed to Umm Kulthum in the market of Kufa, and the other ascribed to Zaynab in the court of Yazid in Damascus. Most Shia authors, however, have later attributed both sermons to Zaynab, which Qutbuddin considers highly likely. Ibn Tayfur writes that the Kufans wailed and wept when they saw Muhammad's family in captivity. Zaynab (or Umm Kulthum) then addressed the crowd and chastised them for their role in Husayn's death and recounted the events of Karbala.

Court of Ibn Ziyad
As reported by al-Tabari and al-Mufid, the captives were then presented to Ibn Ziyad, who boasted to Zaynab about killing Husayn and her relatives. She countered by reminding him of the verse of purification (33:33) and the elevated status of Muhammad's family in the Quran, adding that murder was preordained for Husayn and his supporters, and that God would soon judge between them and Ibn Ziyad. Her response angered the governor who nevertheless restrained himself after his men told him that a woman cannot be blamed for what she says. Ibn Ziyad also ordered the execution of Ali ibn Husayn but was dissuaded when Zaynab protected her nephew and asked to be killed before him, as reported by the early historians Abu Mikhnaf, Ibn Sa'd , and al-Tabari. After releasing the rest, Ibn Ziyad imprisoned the Hashimite captives for a while and then sent them to Damascus.

Journey to Damascus
The caravan's route to Damascus is uncertain, but some say that they took the desert path. The tenth-century Sunni scholar al-Khawrazmi in his writes that the captives were taken from "village to village" and displayed, while the Shia-leaning historian al-Ya'qubi  similarly reports that a letter of Ibn Abbas later reprimanded Yazid for parading the women of Muhammad's family from Kufa to Damascus to show his victory, adding that he deemed this to be worse than the massacre of Husayn and his relatives.

Captives in Damascus


The captives were paraded in the streets of Damascus, and then imprisoned for a while. When they were brought to the caliph, the Islamicist L. Veccia Vaglieri writes that Yazid treated them kindly after an initial harsh interview and regretted the conduct of his governor, even saying that he would have pardoned Husayn if he was alive. Similar accounts are offered by the historians W. Madelung and H. Halm. By contrast, the Islamicist M. Momen believes that Yazid initially treated the captives harshly but later released them as the public opinion began to sway in their favor and he feared unrest in his territory. Views of this kind are expressed by multiple authors, including Esposito, R. Osman, K. Aghaie, D. Pinault, H. Munson, and the Shia scholar M.H. Tabatabai. In particular, the Sunni historian Ibn Kathir writes that Yazid did not reprimand his governor in the wake of the massacre, which does not suggest remorse on his part to the Islamicist H.M. Jafri. Jafri adds that the claims of remorse also contradict the earlier orders of Yazid for his governor to either exact homage from Husayn or kill him.

An alternative account is presented by the Shia scholar Tabarsi and by Abu Mikhnaf. They write that the captives were brought in a ceremony to the caliph, who recited poetry and gloated about avenging his pagan relatives killed in the Battle of Badr (624). By some accounts, Yazid also dishonored the severed head of Husayn with blows from a cane, although this last episode is instead sometimes attributed to Ibn Ziyad, including in the account given by Veccia Vaglieri in which a respectful Yazid blames his governor for killing Husayn. Recounting this last account, Madelung suggests that early (Sunni) sources tend to exonerate the caliph at the cost of Ibn Ziyad. Madelung then argues that the prime responsibility for killing Husayn rests with Yazid.

Zaynab's speech in Damascus
attributes to Zaynab a speech in the court of Yazid, where she is said to have interrupted the caliph's insults and addressed his court harshly, lamenting Husayn, castigating Yazid, and defending the family of Muhammad. In the sermon, the caliph is addressed as "the son of ," where this last word (lit. 'freedmen') is an Islamic reference to those who were pardoned by Muhammad upon his victorious return to Mecca. Yazid is then asked in the sermon if it is just to keep his women guarded and parade the daughters of Muhammad in the streets. As with the Kufa speech, this Damascus sermon is also infused with several Quranic references. For instance, Yazid's victory is called temporary in this sermon, his efforts futile, and his shame eternal. This is coupled with verse 3:179, "Let not disbelievers think that our respite is a good thing. Indeed, we give them respite so that they may increase in trespass, and a shameful punishment awaits them," and verse 11:18, "The curse of God be upon the oppressor," among others.

Other episodes
Reports by al-Tabari and the Shia scholar Ibn Babawayh indicate that a Syrian at one point asked the caliph to give her a daughter of Husayn as a slave but Zaynab angrily prevented this. The Shia jurist Mughniyya writes that Zaynab was asked sarcastically in Damascus how she perceived the events of Karbala, to which she replied, "I have not seen anything except that it was beautiful". For Mughniyya, this response in that hostile environment highlights Zaynab's political strength and vision. A young child of Husayn is said to have died in Damascus, often identified as Sakina, or Ruqayya. The Karbala narrative emphasizes her suffering and death in captivity. In Damascus, the captives continued to mourn Husayn, possibly joined by some women from Yazid's court.

Freedom and return to Medina
The captives were eventually freed. They were allowed to return to Medina, or escorted back there. By some accounts, their caravan returned via Karbala, where they halted to mourn their dead. According to a common Karbala narrative, the family of Muhammad was assisted in this journey by a man named Bashir, who was generously compensated by Zaynab and others from the little that was left after the looting on Ashura. Sunni sources report Yazid's remorse for the massacre and his compensation for the property plundered by his soldiers, while Shia authorities contend that it was Zaynab's activism that swayed some in Yazid's court, especially his women, and thus compelled the caliph to disassociate himself from the massacre and blame his governor. Similar views are expressed by some contemporary authors.

Death (682) and shrines


Zaynab died in 682 at the age of about fifty-six, not long after returning to Medina from Damascus. Alternatively, the historian L. Adamec places her death in the year 681. Shias annually commemorate her death on the most frequently cited date, that is, 15 Rajab. Other reported dates are 11 and 21 of Jumadi al-Thani, 24 Safar, and 16 Dhu al-Hijja.

Little is known about Zaynab's life after returning to Medina, though the silence of al-Tabari about it suggests that she was probably not involved with the nearby uprising of Abd-Allah ibn al-Zubayr. Some reports state that she died in Medina, others say that she travelled with her husband to his Syrian estates, where she died, and yet other sources write that she was exiled, possibly to Egypt, for publicizing Karbala. Her burial place is therefore uncertain, with claims made both for Sayyidah Zaynab Mosque in the suburbs of Damascus and another mosque at the heart of Cairo with the same name. While al-Tabari places her grave in Cairo and the Shia scholar Muhsin al-Amin considers Damascus unlikely, the only key evidence offered in favor of Cairo is the existence of the shrine itself, which officially dates back to the third century AH, supplemented by the testimonies of travellers and notables who lived at least two centuries after Zaynab. The shrines in Damascus and Cairo are both destinations for Muslim pilgrimage, the former often visited by Shias and the latter by Sunnis.

Ritual mourning
Following the precedents set by Zaynab and the Shia imams, Shia Muslims commemorate the Karbala events throughout the months of Muharram and Safar, particularly during the first ten days of Muharram, culminating on Ashura with processions in major Shia cities. The main component of ritual ceremonies is the emotional narration of the stories of Karbala, intended to raise sympathy and move the audience to tears. It is in these ceremonies that Zaynab and other women of Karbala are also commemorated.

Role model
Qutbuddin considers Zaynab a role model for Muslim women and a symbol of "courage, fortitude, leadership, eloquence, devotion, and faith." This view is common, and female Muslim activists have at times cited what they perceived as the steadfast stance of Zaynab against tyranny and oppression, particularly in the recent histories of Iran and Lebanon. Zaynab's birthday is celebrated as Nurses Day in Iran, possibly because she cared for the wounded in Karbala.

Messenger of Karbala
Historically, Karbala served to crystallize the Shia community into a distinct sect and remains an integral part of their religious identity to date. Karbala is perhaps the single most important episode in the history of Shia, where it is viewed as the ultimate struggle of justice and truth against oppression and falsehood, a righteous struggle in which Husayn offered all that was dear to him for the cause of God. In this context, Zaynab has been described as Husayn's partner in his, and the woman whose activism transformed Karbala from a tragedy to a victory. Without her " of words," Karbala may have been forgotten.