| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Punctuation |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Punctuation
|
| Appears to be leaning towards arms control. |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Appears to be leaning towards arms control.
|
| Fourteenth Amendment |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Fourteenth Amendment
|
| German Second Amendment article |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#German Second Amendment article
|
| Suggestions for the German article about the 2nd Amendment |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Suggestions for the German article about the 2nd Amendment
|
| Needs discussion of Silveira v. Lockyer |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Needs discussion of Silveira v. Lockyer
|
| Where is the neutrality dispute? |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Where is the neutrality dispute?
|
| More deleted text |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#More deleted text
|
| Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act
|
| 28 July version |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#28 July version
|
| Text of the Second Amendment |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Text of the Second Amendment
|
| semantics section |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#semantics section
|
| "Civic Model" |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#"Civic Model"
|
| added info re miller |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#added info re miller
|
| Mediator needed to prevent ongoing edit war (2nd Amend.quote) |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 2#Mediator needed to prevent ongoing edit war (2nd Amend.quote)
|
| militia purpose |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 2#militia purpose
|
| Infringed |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Infringed
|
| Who's this 141.156.208.66 guy?! |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 2#Who's this 141.156.208.66 guy?!
|
| Enter Stage Right |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 2#Enter Stage Right
|
| interpretation |
48 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 2#interpretation
|
| The legislative process edit. |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 2#The legislative process edit.
|
| Miller again |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 2#Miller again
|
| The Lead |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#The Lead
|
| Ambiguity |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Ambiguity
|
| Judicial section opening sentence |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Judicial section opening sentence
|
| State's RKBA relevancy to 2A |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#State's RKBA relevancy to 2A
|
| What is the topic of this article? |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#What is the topic of this article?
|
| Editorial suggestions |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Editorial suggestions
|
| Current Judicial Precedence |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Current Judicial Precedence
|
| Introduction |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Introduction
|
| Judicial prededence, child protection laws |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Judicial prededence, child protection laws
|
| Counter-example of a lower Federal Court Case that HAS ruled since the 1939 US v. Miller that the 2A is an individual right |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Counter-example of a lower Federal Court Case that HAS ruled since the 1939 US v. Miller that the 2A is an individual right
|
| 24.145.225.26 edits |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#24.145.225.26 edits
|
| Buzzard |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Buzzard
|
| 2A versus Gun Politics |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#2A versus Gun Politics
|
| Article starting to read more like an honest broker in contentious debate |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Article starting to read more like an honest broker in contentious debate
|
| Anti-Federalists and standing armies |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Anti-Federalists and standing armies
|
| Over reliance on Volokh |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Over reliance on Volokh
|
| Disagreement as to why 2A is not = RKBA |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Disagreement as to why 2A is not = RKBA
|
| Serious problems with modern interpretation section |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Serious problems with modern interpretation section
|
| Clause followed by a right |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Clause followed by a right
|
| What is the point of the section Historical Foundations of Rights to Possess Arms |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#What is the point of the section Historical Foundations of Rights to Possess Arms
|
| State vs. Commonwealth |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#State vs. Commonwealth
|
| Origin of the 2A |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#Origin of the 2A
|
| 1689 |
19 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#1689
|
| common law and amar |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 3#common law and amar
|
| Proposed split |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#Proposed split
|
| Wikifying |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#Wikifying
|
| Ninth and fourteenth amendments and Cruikshank |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#Ninth and fourteenth amendments and Cruikshank
|
| GA nomination |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#GA nomination
|
| discussion of Bobkerrigan edit |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#discussion of Bobkerrigan edit
|
| Proposing to eliminate or revise text |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#Proposing to eliminate or revise text
|
| Patrick Henry quote |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#Patrick Henry quote
|
| Only gentleman could bear a sword |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#Only gentleman could bear a sword
|
| Quotes moved to Wikiquote |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#Quotes moved to Wikiquote
|
| "No evidence" versus "no case" |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 4#"No evidence" versus "no case"
|
| comma debate question |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 5#comma debate question
|
| Presser v. Illinios misquote |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 5#Presser v. Illinios misquote
|
| A little note about the District of Columbia decision and the 9th Circuit Precedent and Fundamental Libertarianism |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 5#A little note about the District of Columbia decision and the 9th Circuit Precedent and Fundamental Libertarianism
|
| Minor terminology change |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 5#Minor terminology change
|
| More Lead rewording |
28 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 5#More Lead rewording
|
| Inflection versus capitalization |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 5#Inflection versus capitalization
|
| Precedents (material added by another editor) |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 5#Precedents (material added by another editor)
|
| Founding Fathers quoted by both sides |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Founding Fathers quoted by both sides
|
| Most Constitutional Scholars do not agree |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 1#Most Constitutional Scholars do not agree
|
| Modern Interpretations section |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 5#Modern Interpretations section
|
| GREAT research resource |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 5#GREAT research resource
|
| Wait, what? |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 6#Wait, what?
|
| Consensus Intro |
35 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#Consensus Intro
|
| NPOV Lead |
39 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 6#NPOV Lead
|
| NPOV lede - section break |
30 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 6#NPOV lede - section break
|
| Second Amendment application to the states sources |
21 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 6#Second Amendment application to the states sources
|
| Interesting note re 2A POV |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 6#Interesting note re 2A POV
|
| How about this suggested lede? |
39 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 6#How about this suggested lede?
|
| Proposal/support: Begin this article with the actual text. Anything else reflects POV. |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 6#Proposal/support: Begin this article with the actual text. Anything else reflects POV.
|
| Article split outs, size trim. |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#Article split outs, size trim.
|
| Yet another proposed intro |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#Yet another proposed intro
|
| Freerepublic |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#Freerepublic
|
| Meaning of the commas |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#Meaning of the commas
|
| Precedent error |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#Precedent error
|
| Gay references in article |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#Gay references in article
|
| NPOV Challenge |
57 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#NPOV Challenge
|
| The word 'most' in the 3rd introductory paragraph. |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#The word 'most' in the 3rd introductory paragraph.
|
| POV tag |
56 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#POV tag
|
| Miller revisited |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Miller revisited
|
| RfC: Balancing POV |
26 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 7#RfC: Balancing POV
|
| States rights |
22 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#States rights
|
| Infringement |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Infringement
|
| State law and state constitutions. |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#State law and state constitutions.
|
| Heavy reliance on origninalism causes POV skew. |
43 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Heavy reliance on origninalism causes POV skew.
|
| edit request |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#edit request
|
| Comments of 4.156.x.x |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Comments of 4.156.x.x
|
| informal vote for consensus; please answer 'yes' or 'no' |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#informal vote for consensus; please answer 'yes' or 'no'
|
| commentary on informal vote above |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#commentary on informal vote above
|
| Article length |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Article length
|
| Militia |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Militia
|
| Originalist theory |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Originalist theory
|
| Small change to "Creation" section |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Small change to "Creation" section
|
| Pro-gun bias in sourcing for Yaf's "state court" section. |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Pro-gun bias in sourcing for Yaf's "state court" section.
|
| Footnote Correction |
26 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Footnote Correction
|
| Impasse |
65 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Impasse
|
| Shortening article |
26 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 8#Shortening article
|
| Link to Parker v DC |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Link to Parker v DC
|
| Text portion of article |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Text portion of article
|
| Well-Regulated |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Well-Regulated
|
| discussion of Yaf's March 12th re-write |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#discussion of Yaf's March 12th re-write
|
| bot assisted archive? |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#bot assisted archive?
|
| Original version |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Original version
|
| Obligation of the feds to ARM the militia |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Obligation of the feds to ARM the militia
|
| Bad Reference in Grammar Section |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Bad Reference in Grammar Section
|
| Bad Reference in origin section |
20 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Bad Reference in origin section
|
| Notation of the questioning of the wording of "the people" |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Notation of the questioning of the wording of "the people"
|
| Misunderstood in the opening part of the wiki is opinionated |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Misunderstood in the opening part of the wiki is opinionated
|
| Bliss |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Bliss 3
|
| Article re-write/clean-up |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#Article re-write/clean-up
|
| restoring POV tag |
19 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 9#restoring POV tag
|
| Requested quote from source for Bliss passage |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Requested quote from source for Bliss passage
|
| The federal government's obligation to arm the militia |
40 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#The federal government's obligation to arm the militia
|
| Informal Poll |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Informal Poll
|
| Unresolved dispute about article neutrality |
33 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Unresolved dispute about article neutrality
|
| Revert of Cooke citation |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Revert of Cooke citation
|
| Quotes |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Quotes
|
| Introduction |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Introduction
|
| District of Columbia v. Heller |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#District of Columbia v. Heller
|
| Incorporation |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Incorporation
|
| District of Columbia v. Heller in Introduction |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#District of Columbia v. Heller in Introduction
|
| Article reform |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Article reform
|
| Post-Heller cases |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Post-Heller cases
|
| Restructuring of the article and lead |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Restructuring of the article and lead
|
| State Gun Laws |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#State Gun Laws
|
| Self-defense as the central component of the right |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Self-defense as the central component of the right
|
| Incorporation in intro |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Incorporation in intro
|
| See also |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#See also
|
| Models of interpretation |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Models of interpretation
|
| The Individual's Right to own a Pocket Warship |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#The Individual's Right to own a Pocket Warship
|
| GA Review |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#GA Review
|
| District of Columbia v. Heller comments |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#District of Columbia v. Heller comments
|
| Introduction |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Introduction
|
| Clarifying meaning of where the 2nd Amendment language was originally going to go |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Clarifying meaning of where the 2nd Amendment language was originally going to go
|
| Errors in Case law section |
30 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Errors in Case law section
|
| Prefatory clause vs. Ablative absolute |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Prefatory clause vs. Ablative absolute
|
| Yaf Please explain |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Yaf Please explain
|
| Case law section causes neutrality skew |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Case law section causes neutrality skew
|
| Problems with the opening sentence |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Problems with the opening sentence
|
| Systemic bias |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Systemic bias
|
| Code words "individual right" in opening sentence cause POV skew |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Code words "individual right" in opening sentence cause POV skew
|
| Pursuant to Kentucky constitution |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Pursuant to Kentucky constitution
|
| Pro-gun bias in the Antebellum period section. |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 10#Pro-gun bias in the Antebellum period section.
|
| Consensus |
36 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#Consensus
|
| Neutrality tag |
26 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Neutrality tag
|
| Federal obligation to ARM the militia |
19 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Federal obligation to ARM the militia
|
| Incorporation, uncertain? |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Incorporation, uncertain?
|
| Over emphasis on Heller, stop fighting. |
22 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Over emphasis on Heller, stop fighting.
|
| Pruning the Article |
29 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Pruning the Article
|
| GA & the POV tag |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#GA & the POV tag
|
| Introduction revision |
30 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Introduction revision
|
| Legislation |
20 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Legislation
|
| NPOV problems |
44 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#NPOV problems
|
| Militia Act of 1903 |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Militia Act of 1903
|
| POV bias on quotes |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#POV bias on quotes
|
| Infringed |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Infringed
|
| Congressional legislation |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Congressional legislation
|
| POV drift |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#POV drift
|
| McClure-Volkmer Act one-sided wording |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#McClure-Volkmer Act one-sided wording
|
| Two versions of the text |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Two versions of the text
|
| Heller's footnote 23 |
28 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Heller's footnote 23
|
| Intro Continues to reflect extensive anti-gun POV |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Intro Continues to reflect extensive anti-gun POV
|
| Hamilton quote still only quote showing - Continuing POV bias |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Hamilton quote still only quote showing - Continuing POV bias
|
| Scope of lede |
50 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Scope of lede
|
| Firearm Owners Protection Act section |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Firearm Owners Protection Act section
|
| Possible new item for the article |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Possible new item for the article
|
| Following comment seems wrong |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Following comment seems wrong
|
| Discussion of states rights. |
34 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Discussion of states rights.
|
| Unpublished source |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Unpublished source
|
| Footnote 67 request full quote |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Footnote 67 request full quote
|
| William Weir sourcing 'dubious'. |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#William Weir sourcing 'dubious'.
|
| Balance missing from the Miller subsection |
27 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Balance missing from the Miller subsection
|
| "extremist" sources |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#"extremist" sources
|
| Not correct |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Not correct
|
| more re the infamous footnote 67 |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#more re the infamous footnote 67
|
| Sounds like a fad |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Sounds like a fad
|
| Quotation request |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Quotation request
|
| Wikipedia policy |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Wikipedia policy
|
| POV problems |
53 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 16#POV problems
|
| POV problems |
28 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#POV problems
|
| Arzberger |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Arzberger
|
| Point 1 - Originalism |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Point 1 - Originalism
|
| Meaning of the term "bear arms", versus "bear" "arms" |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Meaning of the term "bear arms", versus "bear" "arms"
|
| 2. Concealed Carry theory |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#2. Concealed Carry theory
|
| Recent revert |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Recent revert
|
| Shalope quote leading "origin of the right" section is POV push |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Shalope quote leading "origin of the right" section is POV push
|
| Footnote 67 request full quote |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Footnote 67 request full quote
|
| Footnote 67 request full quote |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Footnote 67 request full quote
|
| Brady Campaign POV |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Brady Campaign POV
|
| Misquoting from Cornell's book |
38 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Misquoting from Cornell's book
|
| "To Bear Arms" section should be deleted |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#"To Bear Arms" section should be deleted
|
| Saul Cornell |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 11#Saul Cornell
|
| Second Amendment and gun control |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Second Amendment and gun control
|
| Arzberger is an Eighth Amendment case |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Arzberger is an Eighth Amendment case
|
| New Hampshire threatens to secede from the Union over gun rights |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#New Hampshire threatens to secede from the Union over gun rights
|
| Added material on what constitutes a "well regulated militia" |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Added material on what constitutes a "well regulated militia"
|
| Post Heller court cases |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 13#Post Heller court cases
|
| Origin of the right section has NPOV problem |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Origin of the right section has NPOV problem
|
| Robertson v. Baldwin |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Robertson v. Baldwin
|
| Refactoring talk page comments |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 12#Refactoring talk page comments
|
| Article length |
31 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 16#Article length
|
| Re US v Walters |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Re US v Walters
|
| Re US v Walters |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Re US v Walters
|
| Re US v Walters |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Re US v Walters 2
|
| Anon IP edit war |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Anon IP edit war
|
| Saul Cornell paid mouthpiece of the Joyce Foundation - POV bias issue |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Saul Cornell paid mouthpiece of the Joyce Foundation - POV bias issue
|
| Saul Cornell paid mouthpiece of the Joyce Foundation - POV bias issue |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Saul Cornell paid mouthpiece of the Joyce Foundation - POV bias issue 2
|
| Saul Cornell paid mouthpiece of the Joyce Foundation - POV bias issue |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Saul Cornell paid mouthpiece of the Joyce Foundation - POV bias issue
|
| Saul Cornell paid mouthpiece of the Joyce Foundation - POV bias issue |
28 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 16#Saul Cornell paid mouthpiece of the Joyce Foundation - POV bias issue
|
| Additional POV bias issue - Chicago-Kent Law Review Issue 76 |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Additional POV bias issue - Chicago-Kent Law Review Issue 76
|
| Recent edits/revert |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Recent edits/revert
|
| Low quality material in the article |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Low quality material in the article
|
| Legal right to rebellion and its relations to gun control laws |
22 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Legal right to rebellion and its relations to gun control laws
|
| Wiki uses Mad Hatter as a reference - Seriously ;-) |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Wiki uses Mad Hatter as a reference - Seriously ;-)
|
| Disputing 3rr violation ban likely done by Salty Boatr |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Disputing 3rr violation ban likely done by Salty Boatr
|
| section break |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#section break
|
| section break |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#section break 2
|
| section break |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#section break 3
|
| section break |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#section break 4
|
| Adjust MiszaBot? |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 14#Adjust MiszaBot?
|
| Adjust MiszaBot? |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Adjust MiszaBot?
|
| Adjust MiszaBot? |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Adjust MiszaBot? 2
|
| US v Walters not "YET" a Second Amendment case and should be removed |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#US v Walters not "YET" a Second Amendment case and should be removed
|
| More than two versions |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#More than two versions
|
| Ward does not reference Second Amendment |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Ward does not reference Second Amendment
|
| Anastrophe - consensus on lede |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Anastrophe - consensus on lede
|
| Excessive "concealed carry" and excessive reliance on guncite.com |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Excessive "concealed carry" and excessive reliance on guncite.com
|
| Lysander Spooner |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Lysander Spooner
|
| Excessive use of Saul Cornell" |
41 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Excessive use of Saul Cornell"
|
| heavy handed revert or WP:BRD? |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#heavy handed revert or WP:BRD?
|
| Case law vs Judicial interpretation |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 15#Case law vs Judicial interpretation
|
| New Robertson v. Baldwin belongs under Reconstruction not Antebellum |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 16#New Robertson v. Baldwin belongs under Reconstruction not Antebellum
|
| Presidential administrations |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 16#Presidential administrations
|
| More of Cornell that needs to be weeded out - Comment that CUIKSHANK made a collective rights interpretation |
17 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#More of Cornell that needs to be weeded out - Comment that CUIKSHANK made a collective rights interpretation
|
| Yaf - undue weight |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 16#Yaf - undue weight
|
| Discussion of Ablative Absolute |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Discussion of Ablative Absolute
|
| English Background |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#English Background
|
| Heller and the Debate over the scope of the pre-existing right |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Heller and the Debate over the scope of the pre-existing right
|
| State Ratification Conventions |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#State Ratification Conventions
|
| Mad Hatters out in force |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Mad Hatters out in force
|
| U.S. v. Miller |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#U.S. v. Miller
|
| U.S. v. Cruikshank |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#U.S. v. Cruikshank
|
| Acting outside of concensus and in violation of 3RR |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Acting outside of concensus and in violation of 3RR
|
| Yaf now adding Brady Center propaganda to article - additional POV violation |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Yaf now adding Brady Center propaganda to article - additional POV violation
|
| English Background |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#English Background 2
|
| Statute of Northhampton was DEAD law at time of the American Revolution |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Statute of Northhampton was DEAD law at time of the American Revolution
|
| Right of Revolt |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#Right of Revolt
|
| Conlawgeek |
19 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Conlawgeek
|
| Trial of the Wards (1854) |
33 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#Trial of the Wards (1854)
|
| Serious issues in the "civilian usage meaning" section |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Serious issues in the "civilian usage meaning" section
|
| Adding to obscure arguments and references - here is my contribution - Gun control prohibited by "Bill of Attainder" prohibition |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Adding to obscure arguments and references - here is my contribution - Gun control prohibited by "Bill of Attainder" prohibition
|
| Right to revolt suffers from OR and POV problems |
22 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Right to revolt suffers from OR and POV problems
|
| Unholy Alliance of fascist right and socialist left combine to exclude libertarian fringe |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Unholy Alliance of fascist right and socialist left combine to exclude libertarian fringe
|
| Spooner? |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 17#Spooner?
|
| Milnivlek |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Milnivlek
|
| Issues with recent citation by SaltyBoatr |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Issues with recent citation by SaltyBoatr
|
| Proposing new lede |
46 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Proposing new lede
|
| D.C. v. Heller (2008) |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#D.C. v. Heller (2008)
|
| An example of "foisting" |
27 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#An example of "foisting"
|
| "regulated" |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#"regulated"
|
| Background - English Common Law |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Background - English Common Law
|
| Post Heller Court cases listed by SaltyBoatr |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Post Heller Court cases listed by SaltyBoatr
|
| Chicago suburb bans, Evanston |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Chicago suburb bans, Evanston
|
| NPOV and excessive use of the term "individual" |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#NPOV and excessive use of the term "individual"
|
| Chicago bans upheld based on "Presser v Illinois"; Heller not considered |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Chicago bans upheld based on "Presser v Illinois"; Heller not considered
|
| Spooner and Story |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Spooner and Story
|
| Nathan Kozuskanich |
36 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Nathan Kozuskanich
|
| Second Militia Act of 1792 |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Second Militia Act of 1792
|
| Split the article |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Split the article
|
| Unsourced sentences |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Unsourced sentences
|
| Well Regulated needs work |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Well Regulated needs work
|
| Removed obama quote from 'presidential administrations' sect |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#Removed obama quote from 'presidential administrations' sect
|
| Wholesale removal of word "individual" done without consensus |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Wholesale removal of word "individual" done without consensus
|
| "Regulated" per Online Oxford dictionary |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#"Regulated" per Online Oxford dictionary
|
| Yaf's revert |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 18#Yaf's revert
|
| I believe that Salty Boatr is now in volation of 3RR |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#I believe that Salty Boatr is now in volation of 3RR
|
| SMP - what is OR about this? |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#SMP - what is OR about this?
|
| Issue with the with the word "re-affirmed" in Presser |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Issue with the with the word "re-affirmed" in Presser
|
| Well regulated redux |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Well regulated redux
|
| Incorporation |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Incorporation
|
| removed citiation needed in Presser as nitpicking |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#removed citiation needed in Presser as nitpicking
|
| Synthesis in right to resistance |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Synthesis in right to resistance
|
| RE: Following change in clearly Personal Opinion |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#RE: Following change in clearly Personal Opinion
|
| Following Hamilton quote probably belongs in "Conflict and Compromise" |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Following Hamilton quote probably belongs in "Conflict and Compromise"
|
| Listing "sad consequences" should not be part of the article |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Listing "sad consequences" should not be part of the article
|
| Civilian meaning unbalanced |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#Civilian meaning unbalanced
|
| Is there a source for this material? |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Is there a source for this material?
|
| Move Tushnet |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Move Tushnet
|
| Overuse of "Meaning and Scope ...Contested" |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Overuse of "Meaning and Scope ...Contested"
|
| SaltyBoatr - please do not use "adding cite" when you are adding new material |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#SaltyBoatr - please do not use "adding cite" when you are adding new material
|
| Salty Boatr - please revert your deletion of "balancing" Supreme Court commentary |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Salty Boatr - please revert your deletion of "balancing" Supreme Court commentary
|
| Civilian usage unbalanced |
29 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Civilian usage unbalanced
|
| Do we REALLY need a citation for this? |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Do we REALLY need a citation for this?
|
| Removed unbalanced material regarding "Scholarly reaction" to Heller |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Removed unbalanced material regarding "Scholarly reaction" to Heller
|
| snippet image of BoR |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#snippet image of BoR
|
| Removed Scalia discussion of Scalia Diatribe from intro |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Removed Scalia discussion of Scalia Diatribe from intro
|
| Kozuskanich and Cramer |
39 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 19#Kozuskanich and Cramer
|
| Cool down, let's talk |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#Cool down, let's talk
|
| D.C. v. Heller (2008) |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#D.C. v. Heller (2008)
|
| reminder: this is the talk page for second amendment to the united states constitution |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#reminder: this is the talk page for second amendment to the united states constitution
|
| Nordyke |
64 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#Nordyke
|
| Edit protection lifted |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#Edit protection lifted
|
| Changing Tushnet comment under Background" |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#Changing Tushnet comment under Background"
|
| Dred Scott in Reconstruction part of article |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#Dred Scott in Reconstruction part of article
|
| "of" vs. "to" |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#"of" vs. "to"
|
| New Montana law limits federal powers |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#New Montana law limits federal powers
|
| POV problems, still unresolved, May 2009 |
29 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#POV problems, still unresolved, May 2009
|
| Removed unsourced material |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 20#Removed unsourced material
|
| Contradiction in Text section |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#Contradiction in Text section
|
| Reorganization |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#Reorganization
|
| POV problems |
57 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#POV problems
|
| English background |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#English background
|
| UCLA School of Law Research Paper No. 09-10 |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#UCLA School of Law Research Paper No. 09-10
|
| Let's remove POV tag |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#Let's remove POV tag
|
| Problematic sentence |
39 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#Problematic sentence
|
| constitution.org |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#constitution.org
|
| section break |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#section break 3
|
| Placement of "Early state court decisions" |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#Placement of "Early state court decisions"
|
| section break |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 21#section break
|
| soup |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#soup
|
| Ottaway News Service? |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#Ottaway News Service?
|
| Recommend remove mention of Heller from the lede |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#Recommend remove mention of Heller from the lede
|
| POV concerns in Experience in America prior to the U.S. Constitution subsection |
26 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#POV concerns in Experience in America prior to the U.S. Constitution subsection
|
| Reverts of SaltyBoatr |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#Reverts of SaltyBoatr
|
| Tags removed |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#Tags removed
|
| Properly characterizing Saul Cornell |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 22#Properly characterizing Saul Cornell
|
| David Kopel, gun rights activist |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#David Kopel, gun rights activist
|
| Restore version of the "Early State Court Decisions" section |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Restore version of the "Early State Court Decisions" section
|
| Lack of secondary sourcing for Presser v. Illinois, Miller v. Texas and Robertson v. Baldwin and POV issues |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Lack of secondary sourcing for Presser v. Illinois, Miller v. Texas and Robertson v. Baldwin and POV issues
|
| Presser 'dubious' tag |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Presser 'dubious' tag
|
| Problem with second opening paragraph |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Problem with second opening paragraph
|
| Problematic sentence |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Problematic sentence
|
| Suggested change to content under "Drafting and adoption" |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Suggested change to content under "Drafting and adoption"
|
| Commonwealth of Kentucky law arcana details |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Commonwealth of Kentucky law arcana details
|
| Events after adoption |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Events after adoption
|
| Right to bear arms, OED and OR |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Right to bear arms, OED and OR
|
| Rewrite of Experience in America prior to the U.S. Constitution section |
94 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Rewrite of Experience in America prior to the U.S. Constitution section
|
| Noticeboard discussion |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Noticeboard discussion
|
| Edit warring of POV-section tag |
21 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Edit warring of POV-section tag
|
| "right to arms" does not equal "right to keep and bear arms" |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#"right to arms" does not equal "right to keep and bear arms"
|
| Constitution is about powers and authorities of the state; the bill of rights is about rights of the of the people: |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Constitution is about powers and authorities of the state; the bill of rights is about rights of the of the people:
|
| Moved material |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 23#Moved material
|
| Loyalists versus Patriots in the American Revolution |
22 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Loyalists versus Patriots in the American Revolution
|
| Further Cornell footnote |
36 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Further Cornell footnote
|
| Good Article |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Good Article
|
| Recent Ferrylodge revert |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Recent Ferrylodge revert
|
| Ferrylodge has vanished |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Ferrylodge has vanished
|
| Militia and slave control |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Militia and slave control
|
| David Hardy's linkage |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#David Hardy's linkage
|
| 2nd Amendment as applied to states and the District |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#2nd Amendment as applied to states and the District
|
| Introduction |
35 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Introduction
|
| States resisting federal gun control laws |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#States resisting federal gun control laws
|
| restriction to federal government in first sentence? |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#restriction to federal government in first sentence?
|
| Saul Cornell overrepresented |
27 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Saul Cornell overrepresented
|
| Recent edit |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Recent edit
|
| I am adding back what was removed |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#I am adding back what was removed
|
| Why just "bear arms" when the right is "to keep AND bear arms"? |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Why just "bear arms" when the right is "to keep AND bear arms"?
|
| deleting fringe extremist sources. |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#deleting fringe extremist sources.
|
| Bad reference for "hastily written" claim |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Bad reference for "hastily written" claim
|
| removal of passage based on source with unclear publication process |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#removal of passage based on source with unclear publication process
|
| Merkel and Uviller are low quality sources |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Merkel and Uviller are low quality sources
|
| RE Cherrypicking objection by Kenosis |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#RE Cherrypicking objection by Kenosis
|
| Garry Wills thinks the Second Amednment is a HOAX and calls Madison a liar - dos this make him a High Quality source? |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#Garry Wills thinks the Second Amednment is a HOAX and calls Madison a liar - dos this make him a High Quality source?
|
| getting along on the talk page |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 24#getting along on the talk page
|
| Kenossis - you are in violation of 3RR |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Kenossis - you are in violation of 3RR
|
| Mark Tushnet info |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Mark Tushnet info
|
| Anon did not agree to SaltyBoatr deletion of Kopel material |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Anon did not agree to SaltyBoatr deletion of Kopel material
|
| deletion of Penn MInority report material from "Early Commentary" secton greaty diminishes that section |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#deletion of Penn MInority report material from "Early Commentary" secton greaty diminishes that section
|
| Brady Campaign material needs to be deleted |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Brady Campaign material needs to be deleted
|
| Reliability - Is the Library of Congress a respected source |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Reliability - Is the Library of Congress a respected source
|
| Fully protected the article against dispute |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Fully protected the article against dispute
|
| WP:SOURCES |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#WP:SOURCES
|
| Crazed looney or respected judge and member of the presidents cabinet - You decide! |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Crazed looney or respected judge and member of the presidents cabinet - You decide!
|
| New Backup for Penn Minority Report |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#New Backup for Penn Minority Report
|
| question for AnonIP |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#question for AnonIP
|
| Disrupted editing |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Disrupted editing
|
| "Pennsylvania minority" |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#"Pennsylvania minority"
|
| Full text of the amendment |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Full text of the amendment
|
| Footnote 113 needs an extra carriage return inserted |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Footnote 113 needs an extra carriage return inserted
|
| Penn Minoriy Report- the REAL story - No POV - No lies - No revisonist history - and most certainly no SLANDER |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Penn Minoriy Report- the REAL story - No POV - No lies - No revisonist history - and most certainly no SLANDER
|
| Is Kenosis and Salty Boatr the same person - you decide |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#Is Kenosis and Salty Boatr the same person - you decide
|
| Uviller and Merkel - clean sweep or not? |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Uviller and Merkel - clean sweep or not?
|
| Look like we are back to an edit war |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Look like we are back to an edit war
|
| AFAICT Kenosis has yet to master Googling |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#AFAICT Kenosis has yet to master Googling
|
| Kenosis/SaltyBoatr trying to have it both ways |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Kenosis/SaltyBoatr trying to have it both ways
|
| Chicago Kent Law Review |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 25#Chicago Kent Law Review
|
| Back to my original complaint of 3 weeks ago |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#Back to my original complaint of 3 weeks ago
|
| AFAICT Kenosis can't count. |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#AFAICT Kenosis can't count.
|
| Explanation of removal of Virginia paragraph |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#Explanation of removal of Virginia paragraph
|
| reqesting specific quote |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#reqesting specific quote
|
| "...delegates in some of the states insisted that the Constitution include a bill of rights. " |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#"...delegates in some of the states insisted that the Constitution include a bill of rights. "
|
| trouble with the recently restored paragraph. |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#trouble with the recently restored paragraph.
|
| Removed sentence |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#Removed sentence
|
| "Similar language appears in many Revolutionary Era state constitutions." sourcing??? |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#"Similar language appears in many Revolutionary Era state constitutions." sourcing???
|
| some glarring errors in the article |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#some glarring errors in the article
|
| changed "undemocratic" to "tyrranical" myself |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#changed "undemocratic" to "tyrranical" myself
|
| Straw Purchase |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#Straw Purchase
|
| United States v. Skoien |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#United States v. Skoien
|
| Recent IP edits |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#Recent IP edits
|
| District of Columbia v. Heller |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#District of Columbia v. Heller
|
| English Common Law DID permit the general populace to bear arms! (contrary to recent edits and one source) |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#English Common Law DID permit the general populace to bear arms! (contrary to recent edits and one source)
|
| Joyce Lee Malcolm references |
33 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Joyce Lee Malcolm references
|
| Primary Sources and Original Research |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#Primary Sources and Original Research
|
| Deleting paragraph of substandard material |
26 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 26#Deleting paragraph of substandard material
|
| proposed addition, moved to talk page |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#proposed addition, moved to talk page
|
| Still have an issue with as well - in the same problem paragraph discussed above |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Still have an issue with as well - in the same problem paragraph discussed above
|
| Kenosis |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Kenosis
|
| Documents on Constitution.org dealt with already -one year ago |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Documents on Constitution.org dealt with already -one year ago
|
| Yet another positive view of the Penn report |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Yet another positive view of the Penn report
|
| Clarification in "Scholarly commentary" section |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Clarification in "Scholarly commentary" section
|
| Heller historians brief |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Heller historians brief
|
| Rakove and Bellesiles - Is Rakove a reliable source? |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Rakove and Bellesiles - Is Rakove a reliable source?
|
| New material |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#New material
|
| English history section needs some work |
17 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#English history section needs some work
|
| -Hauskalainen - use of primary documents |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#-Hauskalainen - use of primary documents
|
| Links in footnotes are messed up |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Links in footnotes are messed up
|
| Open for discussion of recent edits |
28 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Open for discussion of recent edits
|
| A well regulated mansion? controlled by umpteen laws? I think not! |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#A well regulated mansion? controlled by umpteen laws? I think not!
|
| SB - your enlargement of Hamiltons quote is not appropriate to the article |
23 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#SB - your enlargement of Hamiltons quote is not appropriate to the article
|
| Academic criticism of Heller |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Academic criticism of Heller
|
| Why is there no section on the Constitutional ratification process? |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Why is there no section on the Constitutional ratification process?
|
| Feudalism, fiefdom, policing laws are NOT relevant to the English Bill of Rights on which 2A is based |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 27#Feudalism, fiefdom, policing laws are NOT relevant to the English Bill of Rights on which 2A is based
|
| Kenosis - Massachusetts Compromise |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Kenosis - Massachusetts Compromise
|
| England Section looking poor at this time |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#England Section looking poor at this time
|
| The REAL reason why the English have historically had a right to arms |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#The REAL reason why the English have historically had a right to arms
|
| Deletion of claims that the Bill of Rights was a victory of one class over another |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Deletion of claims that the Bill of Rights was a victory of one class over another
|
| Explain these reverts please... |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Explain these reverts please...
|
| English History: Connection between the English and American Bill of Rights re right to arms |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#English History: Connection between the English and American Bill of Rights re right to arms
|
| Concerning Footnotes, Format, and Flaming |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Concerning Footnotes, Format, and Flaming
|
| Concerning the Obsession of Some to Clarify the Language of Article VII |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Concerning the Obsession of Some to Clarify the Language of Article VII
|
| Allegations of POV and OR in this so-called edit correction |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Allegations of POV and OR in this so-called edit correction
|
| Warning! |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Warning!
|
| Dispute Resolution - formal or through TALK? |
20 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Dispute Resolution - formal or through TALK?
|
| Sandbox |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Sandbox
|
| English Section - Possible Compromise |
27 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#English Section - Possible Compromise
|
| SB/Hauskalainen - rules on edit war and 3 revert rule |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#SB/Hauskalainen - rules on edit war and 3 revert rule
|
| English Section - Prelude to taking this dispute to dispute resolution. Sub-points of issue |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#English Section - Prelude to taking this dispute to dispute resolution. Sub-points of issue
|
| There came an obligation on SOME to bear arms for a limited purpose |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#There came an obligation on SOME to bear arms for a limited purpose
|
| the right of everyone to bear arms came first to America in the text of the constitution (as amended by the Second Amendment) |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#the right of everyone to bear arms came first to America in the text of the constitution (as amended by the Second Amendment)
|
| Reliable sources |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Reliable sources
|
| Joyce Lee Malcolm references in Heller |
21 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Joyce Lee Malcolm references in Heller
|
| Lund seems to be suffering some sort of schizophrenia |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 28#Lund seems to be suffering some sort of schizophrenia
|
| English History section dispute |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#English History section dispute
|
| Dispute resolution |
19 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Dispute resolution
|
| Dispute resolution |
19 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Dispute resolution 2
|
| RfC: Ancient English history of the US Second Amendment |
52 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#RfC: Ancient English history of the US Second Amendment
|
| Common law right to arms prior to English Bill of Rights |
27 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Common law right to arms prior to English Bill of Rights
|
| Blackstone's Commentaries are a SECONDARY SOURCE |
17 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Blackstone's Commentaries are a SECONDARY SOURCE
|
| The Above Mess is Evading the Main Point |
27 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#The Above Mess is Evading the Main Point
|
| Selective Blindness |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Selective Blindness
|
| Dispute over wording of the English History section. |
58 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#Dispute over wording of the English History section.
|
| A Developing right? |
31 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#A Developing right?
|
| McDonald decision |
26 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#McDonald decision
|
| Edit request from Usmc85, 29 June 2010 |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Edit request from Usmc85, 29 June 2010
|
| McDonald as it pertains to the ancient English History section |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#McDonald as it pertains to the ancient English History section
|
| Natural right |
19 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Natural right
|
| wikilink to "natural rights" article was again deleted |
27 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#wikilink to "natural rights" article was again deleted
|
| NH Constitution and Natural Rights |
36 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#NH Constitution and Natural Rights
|
| Maloney v. Rice - vacated & remanded |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Maloney v. Rice - vacated & remanded
|
| Edit request from Lrenh, 1 July 2010 |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Edit request from Lrenh, 1 July 2010
|
| Chicago Kent problem issue |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Chicago Kent problem issue
|
| RfC: English History Section of this article |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#RfC: English History Section of this article
|
| Edit request from Dbebell, 2 July 2010 |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Edit request from Dbebell, 2 July 2010
|
| Slave control in slave states |
21 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Slave control in slave states
|
| Salty Boatr - You are already in violation of 3RR |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Salty Boatr - You are already in violation of 3RR
|
| Salty - please respond |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Salty - please respond
|
| Hey, guys |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Hey, guys
|
| Proposed edit to Introduction |
44 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Proposed edit to Introduction
|
| Hauskalainen |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 29#Hauskalainen
|
| Survey: Should we agree to seek help from formal mediation? |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Survey: Should we agree to seek help from formal mediation?
|
| section break |
54 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#section break
|
| Governments secure "natural" rights - they do not "grant" them |
17 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#Governments secure "natural" rights - they do not "grant" them
|
| The question is the wording of the English History section. |
19 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#The question is the wording of the English History section.
|
| Typo |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#Typo
|
| 18th and 19th century style |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#18th and 19th century style
|
| Mis-interpretation of Blackstone, natural rights |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Mis-interpretation of Blackstone, natural rights
|
| Another useful source for the English History section - Bodenhamer |
17 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Another useful source for the English History section - Bodenhamer
|
| Typo |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 30#Typo 2
|
| And another, Uviller and Merkel |
28 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#And another, Uviller and Merkel
|
| And another source, Robert Cottrol |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#And another source, Robert Cottrol
|
| Requested move |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Requested move
|
| Counteracting Confirmation Bias? |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Counteracting Confirmation Bias?
|
| Patrick Henry was a hardcore pro-guns advocate |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Patrick Henry was a hardcore pro-guns advocate
|
| "Civic duty" viewpoint infests the article like a pus-filled cancer |
20 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#"Civic duty" viewpoint infests the article like a pus-filled cancer
|
| Is Wills a piss poor source? If Salty quoted him right then yes he is. |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Is Wills a piss poor source? If Salty quoted him right then yes he is.
|
| Whitehill - Direct quotes from link - No OR |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Whitehill - Direct quotes from link - No OR
|
| Propose that the section -Meaning of "to keep and bear arms" - be cut down |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Propose that the section -Meaning of "to keep and bear arms" - be cut down
|
| Slave control in slave states |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Slave control in slave states 2
|
| Self protection within the home |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Self protection within the home
|
| Introduction & reference to individual rights |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Introduction & reference to individual rights
|
| Proposed updating of last sentence of the lead |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Proposed updating of last sentence of the lead
|
| INTRO: "protects each person's right" |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#INTRO: "protects each person's right"
|
| Latest Flurry of Changes in the Lead |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Latest Flurry of Changes in the Lead
|
| Noticed that Salty deleted the cite to the online Oxford dictionary |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Noticed that Salty deleted the cite to the online Oxford dictionary
|
| Proposed New Section |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Proposed New Section
|
| Meaning of "well regulated militia", the Standard Model |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Meaning of "well regulated militia", the Standard Model
|
| Explanation of the POV tag |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 31#Explanation of the POV tag
|
| Anyone know what DeConde is supposed to be a reference to |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Anyone know what DeConde is supposed to be a reference to
|
| SaltyBoatr's request for full protection |
22 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#SaltyBoatr's request for full protection
|
| Proposed Revised Lead |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Proposed Revised Lead
|
| Anything Else? |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Anything Else?
|
| Decouple |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Decouple
|
| This is probably OR or synthesis or contrary to some other wiki policy BUT |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#This is probably OR or synthesis or contrary to some other wiki policy BUT
|
| Salty you are now WAY PAST a 3rr violation |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Salty you are now WAY PAST a 3rr violation
|
| Blatant POV pushing by SaltyBoatr |
22 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Blatant POV pushing by SaltyBoatr
|
| Salty there is a 3rr violation being filed against you |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Salty there is a 3rr violation being filed against you
|
| WP:V of "This article is badly outdated due to recent Supreme Court Decisions" |
27 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#WP:V of "This article is badly outdated due to recent Supreme Court Decisions"
|
| Edits of user Miguel Escopeta |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Edits of user Miguel Escopeta
|
| Oxford Dictionaries Online is not the Oxford English Dictionary |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Oxford Dictionaries Online is not the Oxford English Dictionary
|
| Forward Progress? |
38 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Forward Progress?
|
| Anon's edit of July 27 |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Anon's edit of July 27
|
| For Salty |
23 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#For Salty
|
| Judicial interpretation |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Judicial interpretation
|
| Article lacks section on Ratification of the Constitution |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Article lacks section on Ratification of the Constitution
|
| This 'well regulated' edit needs explanation |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#This 'well regulated' edit needs explanation
|
| Changes to Lead? |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Changes to Lead?
|
| Proposed new section: "US Supreme Court Determinations" |
32 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Proposed new section: "US Supreme Court Determinations"
|
| Revisiting the Oxford dictionary meaning of to bear arms |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Revisiting the Oxford dictionary meaning of to bear arms
|
| Revisit the Lead? |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Revisit the Lead?
|
| Workspace for discussed new section on Supreme Court Determinations |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Workspace for discussed new section on Supreme Court Determinations
|
| Workspace for discussed new section on Supreme Court Determinations |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Workspace for discussed new section on Supreme Court Determinations 2
|
| Analysis of Supreme Court Rulings |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Analysis of Supreme Court Rulings
|
| POV marking |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#POV marking
|
| Another FP request by SaltyBoatr |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Another FP request by SaltyBoatr
|
| Lead |
34 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Lead
|
| Individuals Bearing Arms |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Individuals Bearing Arms
|
| Reversion of New Supreme Court Determinations Section |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Reversion of New Supreme Court Determinations Section
|
| The 200 |
17 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#The 200
|
| Ratification debates |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Ratification debates
|
| SMP0328 - Heller syllabi |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#SMP0328 - Heller syllabi
|
| Case Study of Blockade of this Article - Its Time To Take a Stand |
30 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Case Study of Blockade of this Article - Its Time To Take a Stand
|
| Importance of Heller poll |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Importance of Heller poll
|
| Poll, should we limit use of sourcing about Heller to material published in 2008? |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Poll, should we limit use of sourcing about Heller to material published in 2008?
|
| Longer Term Article Organization |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Longer Term Article Organization
|
| Lede wording issue |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Lede wording issue
|
| New Section?: "Post Heller / McDonald Legal Developments" ? |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#New Section?: "Post Heller / McDonald Legal Developments" ?
|
| United States v. Skoien |
45 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#United States v. Skoien
|
| Elimination of Supreme Court Rulings Section |
50 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Elimination of Supreme Court Rulings Section
|
| Does Gary Wills represents a small fringe opinion |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Does Gary Wills represents a small fringe opinion
|
| Systemic editor bias |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#Systemic editor bias
|
| "Meaning of to keep and bear arms" section. |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 32#"Meaning of to keep and bear arms" section.
|
| How best to cover the "collective" view |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#How best to cover the "collective" view
|
| Articles of Confederation |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Articles of Confederation
|
| Militia suppression of slave insurrection and the 2A |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Militia suppression of slave insurrection and the 2A
|
| At least one of Salty's supposed cites for slave control is bullcrap |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#At least one of Salty's supposed cites for slave control is bullcrap
|
| At what point does Salty's attempts to push his discredited POV by deleting mainstream material become vandalism? |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#At what point does Salty's attempts to push his discredited POV by deleting mainstream material become vandalism?
|
| US Supreme Court Determinations |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#US Supreme Court Determinations
|
| US Supreme Court Determinations |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#US Supreme Court Determinations 2
|
| Trying to formulate roadmap proposal, questions about reference format. |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Trying to formulate roadmap proposal, questions about reference format.
|
| Trying to formulate roadmap proposal, questions about reference format. |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Trying to formulate roadmap proposal, questions about reference format. 2
|
| Why is the prehistory included here? |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Why is the prehistory included here?
|
| "Grammatically correct" punctuation? |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#"Grammatically correct" punctuation?
|
| POV sections on "the meaning of X" |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#POV sections on "the meaning of X"
|
| Unsourced Anonymous Commentary |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Unsourced Anonymous Commentary
|
| Correct Text |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Correct Text
|
| 1/2 of a road map proposal |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#1/2 of a road map proposal
|
| Unsourced Addition |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Unsourced Addition
|
| Heller and new paradigm |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Heller and new paradigm
|
| English Bill of Rights of 1689 |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#English Bill of Rights of 1689
|
| Assize of Arms |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Assize of Arms
|
| Interpreted vs. Reinterpreted |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Interpreted vs. Reinterpreted
|
| English versus American law |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#English versus American law
|
| English History |
59 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#English History
|
| English vs. British |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#English vs. British
|
| Meaning of "Well Regulated Militia" |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Meaning of "Well Regulated Militia"
|
| Dred Scott |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Dred Scott
|
| A few questions: |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#A few questions:
|
| Text section formatting |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Text section formatting
|
| Capitalization |
14 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Capitalization
|
| Early state court decisions |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Early state court decisions
|
| Bill Of Rights defunct in Britain |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Bill Of Rights defunct in Britain
|
| English Bill of Rights subsection |
29 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#English Bill of Rights subsection
|
| Later commentary/Historical models of interpretation |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Later commentary/Historical models of interpretation
|
| The Text should be emphasized using one of the quote templates |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#The Text should be emphasized using one of the quote templates
|
| Nordyke citation |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Nordyke citation
|
| Individual Rights |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Individual Rights
|
| Ratification debate and its purpose |
22 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Ratification debate and its purpose
|
| Only Amendment to not have main text c quote format?? Why? |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Only Amendment to not have main text c quote format?? Why?
|
| NPOV in the Introduction |
49 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#NPOV in the Introduction
|
| Recent addition & deletion regarding dicta |
20 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Recent addition & deletion regarding dicta
|
| Note on Precedent |
33 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Note on Precedent
|
| Court material added by Liko81 and then reverted |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Court material added by Liko81 and then reverted
|
| Summary of incident |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Summary of incident
|
| Does Miller belong in the lead? |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Does Miller belong in the lead?
|
| Lede |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Lede
|
| Stupid |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Stupid
|
| Should Herrington v. United States be in the article? |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Should Herrington v. United States be in the article?
|
| Criticism |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Criticism
|
| Late 20th century commentary section needs work |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Late 20th century commentary section needs work
|
| Tyrannical government |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Tyrannical government
|
| Reliable or not reliable? |
30 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Reliable or not reliable?
|
| This article is POV |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#This article is POV
|
| Lede discussion revived from archive. Please do not archive until consensus is reached on lede |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Lede discussion revived from archive. Please do not archive until consensus is reached on lede
|
| Lede discussion revived from archive. Please do not archive until consensus is reached on lede |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Lede discussion revived from archive. Please do not archive until consensus is reached on lede
|
| Who the Heck is Davies? |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Who the Heck is Davies?
|
| District of Columbia v. Heller - documentation error |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#District of Columbia v. Heller - documentation error
|
| Edit request on 14 January 2013 |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Edit request on 14 January 2013
|
| Recent attempts to change the lede |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Recent attempts to change the lede
|
| Recent attempts to change the lede |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Recent attempts to change the lede 2
|
| Recent attempts to change the lede |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Recent attempts to change the lede
|
| "Generally accepted" that Second Amendment confers individual right is POV |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#"Generally accepted" that Second Amendment confers individual right is POV
|
| "Generally accepted" that Second Amendment confers individual right is POV |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#"Generally accepted" that Second Amendment confers individual right is POV 2
|
| "Generally accepted" that Second Amendment confers individual right is POV |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#"Generally accepted" that Second Amendment confers individual right is POV
|
| Both sides of "militia" controversy should be mentioned. Strong POV problem |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Both sides of "militia" controversy should be mentioned. Strong POV problem
|
| Both sides of "militia" controversy should be mentioned. Strong POV problem |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Both sides of "militia" controversy should be mentioned. Strong POV problem 2
|
| Both sides of "militia" controversy should be mentioned. Strong POV problem |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Both sides of "militia" controversy should be mentioned. Strong POV problem
|
| Slave patrols |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Slave patrols
|
| Concise evolution of understanding about the meaning of the Second Amendment |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Concise evolution of understanding about the meaning of the Second Amendment
|
| Concise evolution of understanding about the meaning of the Second Amendment |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Concise evolution of understanding about the meaning of the Second Amendment 2
|
| Concise evolution of understanding about the meaning of the Second Amendment |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Concise evolution of understanding about the meaning of the Second Amendment
|
| Arms policies in Europe |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Arms policies in Europe
|
| New lede |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#New lede
|
| New lede |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#New lede 2
|
| New lede |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#New lede
|
| Possible revisions in lead |
32 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Possible revisions in lead
|
| Request re Perkins |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Request re Perkins
|
| Talk page guide lines |
56 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Talk page guide lines
|
| Is the Supreme Court correspondent of the New York Times used frequently in wikipedia a reliable source? |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Is the Supreme Court correspondent of the New York Times used frequently in wikipedia a reliable source?
|
| Is the Supreme Court correspondent of the New York Times used frequently in wikipedia a reliable source? |
11 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Is the Supreme Court correspondent of the New York Times used frequently in wikipedia a reliable source?
|
| Edit request on 4 February 2013 |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 33#Edit request on 4 February 2013
|
| Edit request on 4 February 2013 |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Edit request on 4 February 2013
|
| RFC |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#RFC
|
| Two different versions of the second amendment |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Two different versions of the second amendment
|
| Proposed New Lead to Mention Prior Collective View as Well as Current Individual View |
41 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Proposed New Lead to Mention Prior Collective View as Well as Current Individual View
|
| Can we reach a lede consensus |
81 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Can we reach a lede consensus
|
| Elephant in the room |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Elephant in the room
|
| New Tenth Circuit decision |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#New Tenth Circuit decision
|
| Full protection |
32 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Full protection
|
| missing comma |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#missing comma
|
| Changes to Lead re Miller |
28 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Changes to Lead re Miller
|
| protects vs concerns |
35 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#protects vs concerns
|
| Statements in lead regarding pre-Heller situation and individual vs. collective-only |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Statements in lead regarding pre-Heller situation and individual vs. collective-only
|
| Let's use the other Amendment articles as a guide for the lead |
30 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Let's use the other Amendment articles as a guide for the lead
|
| Response to Greek |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Response to Greek
|
| Can vague recollections trump reliable sources? |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Can vague recollections trump reliable sources?
|
| Need to stop grinding on the lead |
25 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Need to stop grinding on the lead
|
| Talk page guide lines |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Talk page guide lines
|
| Breyer's dissent |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Breyer's dissent
|
| Sources |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Sources
|
| Full protection thread |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 34#Full protection thread
|
| New first sentence rev 2 |
36 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#New first sentence rev 2
|
| scope |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#scope
|
| Nunn |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Nunn
|
| Article the Fourth |
19 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Article the Fourth
|
| Just a note.... |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Just a note....
|
| 20th century views expansion |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#20th century views expansion
|
| Conflict and compromise in Congress produce the Bill of Rights |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Conflict and compromise in Congress produce the Bill of Rights
|
| Supreme Court cases |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Supreme Court cases
|
| NPOV Dispute (Ratification Debates) |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#NPOV Dispute (Ratification Debates)
|
| Official text |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Official text
|
| Synthesis |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Synthesis
|
| Second Amendment article practically useless -- riddled with POV |
34 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Second Amendment article practically useless -- riddled with POV
|
| Analysis of Congressional Research Service report |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Analysis of Congressional Research Service report
|
| We need to be clear about our disagreements. |
29 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#We need to be clear about our disagreements.
|
| Ahemmmm..... |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Ahemmmm.....
|
| Miller on individual right |
17 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Miller on individual right
|
| Limited right |
20 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Limited right
|
| Is the Supreme Court description of the Miller case in a published opinion in 1980 (Lewis) a reliable source for how the Supreme Court viewed Miller in 1980? |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Is the Supreme Court description of the Miller case in a published opinion in 1980 (Lewis) a reliable source for how the Supreme Court viewed Miller in 1980?
|
| Consensus? |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Consensus?
|
| Neutrality Dispute |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Neutrality Dispute
|
| Request for Comment - Include Prior Law? |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Request for Comment - Include Prior Law?
|
| Dispute resolution |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Dispute resolution
|
| Added the disputed template to the top of the article |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Added the disputed template to the top of the article
|
| Lead |
18 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Lead
|
| Article protected |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Article protected
|
| This is a great start, why are we not using this? |
30 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#This is a great start, why are we not using this?
|
| 2nd draft with proper coding |
76 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#2nd draft with proper coding
|
| Being bold |
16 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Being bold
|
| Article style |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Article style
|
| Lead revisited |
24 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Lead revisited
|
| Lede secondary sources |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Lede secondary sources
|
| Additional lede references |
47 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Additional lede references
|
| Proposal for lead |
69 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Proposal for lead
|
| Arbitrary break |
50 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Arbitrary break
|
| Can everyone please refrain from editing the lead while we are still discussing it? |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Can everyone please refrain from editing the lead while we are still discussing it?
|
| Correct term |
29 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Correct term
|
| Groups |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Groups
|
| Citizens versus non-citizens |
12 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Citizens versus non-citizens
|
| Paragraph breaks in the lead |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Paragraph breaks in the lead
|
| Not unlimited |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Not unlimited
|
| Slavery |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Slavery
|
| The right is not unlimited and does not prohibit all forms of gun regulation |
29 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#The right is not unlimited and does not prohibit all forms of gun regulation
|
| Does not prohibit regulation |
17 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Does not prohibit regulation
|
| Prohibition, qualifiers or not? Suggestion Reply |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Prohibition, qualifiers or not? Suggestion Reply
|
| knives, other arms |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#knives, other arms
|
| Militia |
42 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Militia
|
| More commentary |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#More commentary
|
| Removing "8.3 Miller v. Texas" from the wiki page "Second Amendment to the United States Constitution" |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Removing "8.3 Miller v. Texas" from the wiki page "Second Amendment to the United States Constitution"
|
| First sentence |
58 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#First sentence
|
| Potentially upcoming scotus cases |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Potentially upcoming scotus cases
|
| New Ninth Circuit decision |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#New Ninth Circuit decision
|
| I'm not a lawyer: I just see a bunch of trees and no forest here |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#I'm not a lawyer: I just see a bunch of trees and no forest here
|
| Polls |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Polls
|
| Misplaced sentence |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Misplaced sentence
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 23 May 2014 |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Semi-protected edit request on 23 May 2014
|
| Peruta v. San Diego decision in the Ninth Circuit |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Peruta v. San Diego decision in the Ninth Circuit
|
| Factual error |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Factual error
|
| Proposed edit/addition |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Proposed edit/addition
|
| Starting article with court interpretation |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Starting article with court interpretation
|
| Arms |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Arms
|
| Article needs balance |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Article needs balance
|
| Amending what? |
10 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Amending what?
|
| Gun Control |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Gun Control
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 13 September 2014 |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Semi-protected edit request on 13 September 2014
|
| Redundant links |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Redundant links
|
| ... of individuals ... |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#... of individuals ...
|
| Court of Appeals Section |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Court of Appeals Section
|
| 2nd Amendment |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#2nd Amendment
|
| Text section issues |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Text section issues
|
| Plagiarism in 'Ratification Debates' |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Plagiarism in 'Ratification Debates'
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 28 March 2015 |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Semi-protected edit request on 28 March 2015
|
| Objective scholarship |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Objective scholarship
|
| Exact wording at the top |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Exact wording at the top
|
| The "deterring tyrannical government" reference |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#The "deterring tyrannical government" reference
|
| Lede is too long and biased |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Lede is too long and biased
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#External links modified
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 26 September 2015 |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Semi-protected edit request on 26 September 2015
|
| Dead citation link |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Dead citation link
|
| Collective, not individual, right |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Collective, not individual, right
|
| Needs updating |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Needs updating
|
| White space |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#White space
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#External links modified 2
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#External links modified 3
|
| Tyrannical government |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Tyrannical government
|
| commas? |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#commas?
|
| History of the suppression of the Scottish militia in the 18th century |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#History of the suppression of the Scottish militia in the 18th century
|
| Debate over importance of 1st and 3rd commas? |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Debate over importance of 1st and 3rd commas?
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 27 June 2016 |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Semi-protected edit request on 27 June 2016
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 4 October 2016 |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Semi-protected edit request on 4 October 2016
|
| Caetano v. Massachusetts |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Caetano v. Massachusetts
|
| Request change for this and all articles about the US Constitution |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Request change for this and all articles about the US Constitution
|
| Anti-federalist vs. federalist, i.e. state's rights vs. federal rights |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Anti-federalist vs. federalist, i.e. state's rights vs. federal rights
|
| Meaning of "the right of the People" |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Meaning of "the right of the People"
|
| Table |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Table
|
| False Statement |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#False Statement
|
| The actual words of the 2nd Amendment appear too late in the article |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#The actual words of the 2nd Amendment appear too late in the article
|
| English background |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#English background
|
| Include relatively modern usage of "well-regulated" |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Include relatively modern usage of "well-regulated"
|
| Intent of framers per Declaration of Independence |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Intent of framers per Declaration of Independence
|
| Typo or just bad grammar? |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Typo or just bad grammar?
|
| Protected edit request on 25 February 2018 |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Protected edit request on 25 February 2018
|
| Protected edit request on 27 February 2018 |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Protected edit request on 27 February 2018
|
| Protected edit request on 28 February 2018 |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Protected edit request on 28 February 2018
|
| citation #61 |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#citation #61
|
| Commas |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Commas
|
| Nothing under "See Also" re. state constitution analogs to federal constitution 2nd A |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Nothing under "See Also" re. state constitution analogs to federal constitution 2nd A
|
| Hubert Humphrey quote |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Hubert Humphrey quote
|
| Section: "Meaning of 'the right of the People'" |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Section: "Meaning of 'the right of the People'"
|
| The Lede Section |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#The Lede Section
|
| #NeverAgain |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35##NeverAgain
|
| "Repeal" section |
6 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#"Repeal" section
|
| State constitutional precursors |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#State constitutional precursors
|
| Burger was objectively conservative |
15 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Burger was objectively conservative
|
| Cooley quote |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Cooley quote
|
| Attempt at compromise |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Attempt at compromise
|
| Reject "supports the Second Amendment" phraseology |
9 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Reject "supports the Second Amendment" phraseology
|
| Two issues with the introduction |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Two issues with the introduction
|
| Safeguarding Against Tyranny |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Safeguarding Against Tyranny
|
| What Heller did |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#What Heller did
|
| First sentence must include everything the amendment declares and restricts. |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#First sentence must include everything the amendment declares and restricts.
|
| Lead should introduce the amendment as accurately as possible, given multiple interpretations |
5 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Lead should introduce the amendment as accurately as possible, given multiple interpretations
|
| The right to a well-regulated militia, or not |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#The right to a well-regulated militia, or not
|
| Removing "individual" from lede |
13 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Removing "individual" from lede
|
| How is this not a semi-protected article? |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#How is this not a semi-protected article?
|
| A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion
|
| A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for speedy deletion |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for speedy deletion
|
| Calls for repeal -- Undue Weight |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Calls for repeal -- Undue Weight
|
| Preserving Slave Patrols Hartmann and Carl Bogus |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Preserving Slave Patrols Hartmann and Carl Bogus
|
| Introductory description of the Second Amendment |
8 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Introductory description of the Second Amendment
|
| Bacon's Rebellion and the Virginia Slave Codes of 1705 |
3 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Bacon's Rebellion and the Virginia Slave Codes of 1705
|
| An article discussing a constitutional amendment should begin with the actual amendment |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#An article discussing a constitutional amendment should begin with the actual amendment
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment
|
| Regarding section "Argument for state power" |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Regarding section "Argument for state power"
|
| The right to bear arms, here only in the context of a "well regulated militia", right? |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#The right to bear arms, here only in the context of a "well regulated militia", right?
|
| Meaning of “Shall not be infringed " |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Meaning of “Shall not be infringed "
|
| Text |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Text
|
| "Security of a Free State" meaning National Defense in 1791 |
7 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#"Security of a Free State" meaning National Defense in 1791
|
| British Bill of Rights 1689 |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#British Bill of Rights 1689
|
| Court of Appeals Section |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Court of Appeals Section 2
|
| Federalist Paper #29 should be mentioned? and Is fear of slave revolt part of the reason for support for this amendment? |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Federalist Paper #29 should be mentioned? and Is fear of slave revolt part of the reason for support for this amendment?
|
| Reason for the 2nd Amendment |
1 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Reason for the 2nd Amendment
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 27 April 2023 |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Semi-protected edit request on 27 April 2023
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 28 April 2023 |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Semi-protected edit request on 28 April 2023
|
| Create subsection of "Scholarly commentary" entitled: Meaning of "shall not be infringed." |
2 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution/Archive 35#Create subsection of "Scholarly commentary" entitled: Meaning of "shall not be infringed."
|
| District of Columbia v. Heller |
4 |
Talk:Second Amendment to the United States Constitution#District of Columbia v. Heller
|
