Talk:Daisy Carter

Regarding that 'Reception' section, out of 5 statements/sources, 4 came from Zap2it. That doesn't show any balance whatsoever.

''Zima was generally negatively received for her portrayal of the role. TV Guide Canada listed Zima's appearance as Daisy in 2010 as the "worst comeback" of a character. The character's background has been criticized; Zap2it said Daisy being the daughter of Sheila and Tom makes "no coherent sense". In 2012, Zap2it called Daisy "the most hated and most awful character in Y&R history". When Zima was let go, Jamey Giddens, a writer from Zap2it, described it as "the day The Young and the Restless fans have been begging for". When the actress was rehired soon after, Jillian Bowe, also from Zap2it, asked new executive producer Jill Farren Phelps and new head writer Josh Griffith to "make their first order of business putting a stop to this nonsense".''

It's practically all about the opinion of one single website, Screener (formerly Zap2it). In 2012, Zap2it called Daisy "the most hated and most awful character in Y&R history". Is that a fact, or is it rather just an exaggerated opinion? Israell (talk) 18:51, 21 August 2017 (UTC)


 * Actually, it's not Zap2it, it's Daytime Confidential back when it was a sub-division fo Zap2it. But, regardless, that's what has been given for reception.  If more can be found, then add it.  But don't just go and do a mass-removal of an ENTIRE section, simply because DC is the one source that is mass-used.   livelikemusic    talk!  18:57, 21 August 2017 (UTC)