Talk:Julia Gardiner Tyler

Misleading Impression
The article currently seems to create a misleading impression about the dates involved. Julia Gardiner's father was killed on February 28, 1844, which was obviously well after Tyler proposed in 1843. The article currently implies that she consented because he "comforted her in her grief," but the dates suggest they had already been secretly engaged for more than a year before her father's death. This should be rewritten. john k (talk) 00:29, 29 June 2008 (UTC)