Talk:List of Philadelphia Phillies no-hitters

Baserunners and managers
It should be interesting to have the number of baserunners in the table. In a no-hit game, opponents can still reach base via a walk, error, or hit by pitch. In a no-hit game without the baserunners, it would be called a perfect game. The number of baserunners somehow determine how close the no-hit game it is to perfect game and estimate how many batters did a pitcher(s) faced. The managers, on the other hand, determine the lineups and starting rotation from time-to-time. Managers determine the order of starting pitchers who may eventually throw a no-hitter(s) or perfect game(s). So having table at full width and putting two images starting in See also section would be great for better fitting of texts in each line. BlueEarth (talk | contribs) 04:21, 15 November 2010 (UTC)
 * Interesting? Perhaps. Necessary for an encyclopedia? Not particularly. You're turning a featured list into a collection of indiscriminate information, prohibited by site policy. I'm asking you to please revert those additions (considering that you violated WP:3RR by reverting again before discussion took place anyway). &mdash; KV5  •  Talk  •  13:24, 22 November 2010 (UTC)

My reversion of 12:39 on December 6 2010
The rationale behind my reversion, which was too long for an edit summary:
 * The editor continues to make sweeping changes to featured content without discussion.
 * The editor improperly re-formatted reference titles.
 * The editor removed summary elements of the list from the lead.
 * The editor expanded the section header above the list to the point of redundancy.
 * The editor added unneeded dates, superfluous information, and countless MOS:NUM violations to the lead.
 * The editor added jargon in the form of "plate umpire", rather than simply umpire.
 * The editor removed Wikipedia-markup templates in favor of bare HTML markup.
 * The editor added several pieces of unnecessary information to the table.

In short, addition of superfluous information is making this list into a collection of indiscriminate information; these sorts of changes should cease or be discussed before further edits are made. &mdash; KV5  •  Talk  •  12:44, 6 December 2010 (UTC)