Talk:The Other Hand

Good job
I am a member of WP:Novels, and came here to assess the page. I like the article, here are some recommendations:

1. Include a more thorough publication history 2. expand the themes section 3. if reviewers discussed the development of certain characters at length include a "Characters" 4. If reviewers discussed the style of writing, build a more thorough approach of "literary style" discuss genre, comparisons made to other books etc. 5. Focus the reception more to what people thought, use the excess information to develop recommendations in 2,3,4.

I think you will be fine on the GA review, good job, hope my comments help. Sadads (talk) 15:44, 13 February 2010 (UTC)

What about the film?
I notice the piece about the "upcoming film". That section is four years old. What has happened with the film? Tanzania (talk) 12:04, 22 November 2014 (UTC)

The article comes off as hopelessly dated given the breathless discussion of a movie that was never made -- indeed, this section reads as if it was written by a publicist for Kidman or Cleave. I edited the section to put references to the film in the past tense with passive voice rather than the future tense, but better would be for someone to cut the section down to a single sentence. PaulAlanLevy (talk) 23:03 20 June 2017) (UTC)