Talk:The Reason I Jump

New York Times - Voice of the Voiceless
The New York Times Sunday Book Review:

Conrad T. Pino (talk) 07:41, 15 January 2014 (UTC)

Facilitated communication has been disproved
Saying that Higashida wrote the book is like saying that John Dee & Edward Kelley were able to summon angels and communicate with them. Facilitated communication is not considered scientific. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 84.250.3.250 (talk) 12:33, 25 February 2017 (UTC)


 * If you watch this video he looked at the paper keyboard, picked alphabets (romaji), and read it out loud without help from someone. Though his pronunciation wasn't perfect it's totally understandable to me, native Japanese speaker.  His grammar and choice of words are perfect though often he constructed the sentence word by word.  In the video he explained that the paper keyboard helped him to keep the memory intact while speaking.  Also I saw him writing his book using the word processor on PC.  He picked correct idioms (Chinense characters, kanjis) without hesitation. It's even faster than using the paper keyboard. I have no doubt in his ability in language.  His speech function is just not working.  — Preceding unsigned comment added by 76.94.237.233 (talk) 09:03, 30 May 2018 (UTC)
 * While whether the Higashidas use FC remains controversial, with the director of the documentary denying it and Temple Grandin giving them the benefit of the doubt, these things are beyond dispute as far as I can tell:
 * Douglas Biklen and Higashida spoke at a "joint lecture/forum" (co-sponsored by Amway) promoting FC.
 * Higashida has appeared in Wretches & Jabberers, a film produced by Biklen.
 * A 2017 paper (which is itself uncritical of FC) said, "In Higashida & Higashida (2005), the procedure of the assisted communication is similar to FC and Soft Touching Assistance [a method devised in Japan], and the accompanying DVD shows Higashida writing a manuscript by typing on the keyboard himself, with his mother in contact with his leg" (p. 16; my translation).
 * The documentary shows usage of FC (or RPM) in the segment shot in the US (as briefly shown in the trailer).
 * What I find most curious is how Higashida and those featured in the documentary learned to spell. Unlike spoken and signed language (or "language", as linguists define it), writing is a technology that needs to be explicitly taught, not just immersed in, in order for anybody to acquire it, and for most people it takes a whole childhood to be competent or even decent at it. Specifically, English orthography is infamously inconsistent and unpredictable with regard to pronunciation correspondence, and the Japanese writing system is notoriously complex with two syllabaries and thousands of kanji characters. If their parents managed to teach them how to write, that's something lots of parents of children with learning disabilities would be eager to know, and if they didn't, it would seem there are proficient hyperlexics among non-/minimally verbal children in an extraordinary proportion. Nardog (talk) 14:52, 14 June 2021 (UTC)
 * I haven't looked into this, but if there are reliable sources questioning the authenticity of Higashida's authorship, then we can reflect this by writing something like "credited to Higashida", before going into detail about the controversy. edit: I didn't see this was such an old discussion. I see the article already does this, seems sensible to me assuming the sources are good. Popcornfud (talk) 15:13, 14 June 2021 (UTC)