User:Ealdgyth/2016 Arb Election votes

It's that time of year again...

Note that I'm looking for folks who have their eye on the main point of this whole enterprise - writing an encyclopedia. With that in mind, I want content contributions, or at least the concept that they support content contributors. If you're an admin or not really doesn't matter to me at all. In fact, NOT being an admin should be a requirement for at least one of the seats, quite honestly. I'm also looking for folks who don't get so wrapped up in enforcing civility or rules that they forget that first goal above, the writing of the encyclopedia. I don't want to have my work interrupted by idiots who don't know the first thing about subject matter but who seem to think that their opinion on some tangental matter should trump the folks in the trenches writing the content and dealing with the vandals.

To that end - I expect folks to have at least 45-50% of their contributions to article space, unless they show a LOT of clue in supporting content creation. Stupid ruleslawyering or spending ages at ANI will not get you much support here. Well, that's a great goal, but no way can I just judge candidates on that ... because very few candidates meet that standard. And a few of the ones that do, are not otherwise qualified, at least in my eyes.

In line with the last few years, I'm much less likely to approve of folks who are hardline on civility, for example. Also note that I do not consider myself suited for ArbCom, I do not deal well with high stress situations nor do I have the tact required. Whether I think someone is suited for ArbCom has nothing to do with whether I think they are good contributors to the project in other means.

As a side note, feel free to drop me a note on my talk page if you wish to discuss any of these.

7 slots. Ugh. 7 slots. How the heck can I possibly find 7 folks to vote for???

Past votes

 * User:Ealdgyth/2009 Arb Election votes
 * User:Ealdgyth/2010 Arb Election votes
 * User:Ealdgyth/2011 Arb Election votes
 * User:Ealdgyth/2012 Arb Election votes
 * User:Ealdgyth/2013 Arb Election votes
 * User:Ealdgyth/2014 Arb Election votes
 * User:Ealdgyth/2015 Arb Election votes

In the spirit of fairness

 * 1)  - Edit tools  94900 edits total, 200 automated (not sure where these come from, since I've never installed Twinkle or Huggle or the like), 94700 manual edits. Account started editing 2007. 66.3% to articles, 10.9% to article talk, 6% to user pages, 6.8% to user talk pages, 8.7% to wikipedia space, 0.7% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back 1.5 months. Over 100 articles with over 100 edits. 8 edits to ANI, less than 7 edits to AN. 1207 pages created, 381 were redirects, so 826 "real" pages created. Is NOT an admin. 1 FT, 2 FLs, 57 FAs, 105 GAs.

Handy!

 * Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/Guide

Weak Support

 * 1)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/DeltaQuad/Questions 30,828 edits total, 3553 automated, 27,275 manual edits. Account started editing 2007. 12.1% to articles, 2.4% to article talk, 15.4% to user pages, 21.8% to user talk pages, 44.4% to wikipedia space, 2.1% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 4 October. No articles with over 100 edits. 98 edits to ANI, 47 edits to AN. 1885 edits in the last 365 days. 102 pages created, 89 were redirects, so 13 "real" pages created. Is an admin. Current member of ArbCom.
 * 2) Alternate account:  - Edit tools  904 edits total, 144 automated, 760 manual edits. 9.3% to articles, 1.3% to article talk, 6.3% to user pages, 18.7% to user talk pages, 60% to wikipedia space, 3.3% to wikipedia talk pages. Alternative account for editing from public computers.
 * 3) Alternate account:  - Edit tools Bot account.
 * 4) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 1 edit, test account.
 * 5) Alternate account:  - Edit tools Old account for AWB, blocked by user.
 * 6) Alternate account:  - Edit tools old account, blocked by user.
 * 7) Alternate account:  - Edit tools Bot account.
 * 8) Ran in 2011 and 2014. I oppposed in 2011 and in 2014. Their work on the committee hasn't been outstanding but it has been acceptable.
 * 9)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/Doug Weller/Questions  161,970 edits total, 36,507 automated, 125,463 manual edits. Account started editing 2006. 49.8% to articles, 11% to article talk, 0.7% to user pages, 28.7% to user talk pages, 7.7% to wikipedia space, 1.7% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 13 November. 37 articles with over 100 edits. 15,221 edits in the last 365 days. 2142 edits to ANI, 405 edits to AN. 167 pages created, 143 were redirects, so 24 "real" pages created. Is an admin. Current member of ArbCom.
 * 10) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 2 edits.
 * 11) Ran in 2014. I supported in 2014. I'm good with Doug's performance on the committee.
 * 12)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/Newyorkbrad/Questions--> 39,541 edits total, 6 automated, 39,535 manual edits. Account started editing 2006. 12.2% to articles, 2.5% to article talk, 1.6% to user pages, 29.1% to user talk pages, 44.9% to wikipedia space, 8.8% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 29 June. 0 articles with over 100 edits. 1539 edits in the last 365 days. 1310 edits to ANI, 555 edits to AN. 370 pages created, 229 were redirects, so 141 "real" pages created. Is an admin. Former member of ArbCom.
 * 13) No alternate accounts.
 * 14) Ran in 2007, 2010, 2012. I wasn't compiling guides in 2007, supported in 2010 and 2012. I'm very very weak on this support. The only thing swinging me into support here is his past record on the committee, which is (ironically) one of the main concerns. I think its entirely possible we've put NYB on the committee too much for his own good....but given the lack of otherwise qualified candidates, I have to weakly support.
 * 15)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/Salvidrim!/Questions 22,256 edits total, 381 automated, 21,875 manual edits. Account started editing 2010. 22.4% to articles, 11.4% to article talk, 7.1% to user pages, 19.3% to user talk pages, 29.4% to wikipedia space, 6.5% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 11 November. 0 articles with over 100 edits. 3477 edits in the last 365 days. 163 edits to ANI, 638 edits to AN. 336 pages created, 301 were redirects, so 35 "real" pages created. Is an admin.
 * 16) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 12 edits
 * 17) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 6 edits
 * 18) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 8 edits
 * 19) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 0 edits
 * 20) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 0 edits
 * 21) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 0 edits
 * 22) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 0 edits
 * 23) Ran in 2015 and withdrew. Like the answers to the questions. Nothing else is screaming "no" so going with support on this one.

Oppose

 * 1)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/Ks0stm/Questions 17,417 edits total, 4243 automated, 13,174 manual edits. Account started editing 2007. 25.9% to articles, 6% to article talk, 5.7% to user pages, 29.9% to user talk pages, 25.9% to wikipedia space, 2.1% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 10 November. 1 article with over 100 edits. 2893 edits in the last 365 days. 224 edits to ANI, 55 edits to AN. 124 pages created, 90 were redirects, so 34 "real" pages created. Is an admin.
 * 2) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 250 edits
 * 3) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 12 edits
 * 4) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 451 edits
 * 5) Alternate account:  - Edit tools No edits.
 * 6) Alternate account:  - Edit tools No edits
 * 7) Alternate account:  - Edit tools No edits.
 * 8) Ran in 2012, 2013, and 2014. I opposed in 2012, 2013, and 2014. I'm doubting I'll change my mind here. Opposing because of past opposition. Not seeing a lot to make me change my past belief.
 * 9)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/LFaraone/Questions 16,889 edits total, 2351 automated, 14,538 manual edits. Account started editing 2004. 29.9% to articles, 10.1% to article talk, 3.6% to user pages, 19.5% to user talk pages, 34.6% to wikipedia space, 1% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 14 September 2015. 1 article with over 100 edits. 242 edits in the last 365 days. Under 33 edits to ANI, Under 33 edits to AN. 161 pages created, 146 were redirects, so 15 "real" pages created. Is an admin. Former member of ArbCom.
 * 10) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 1 edit
 * 11) Alternate account:  - Edit tools No edits
 * 12) Ran in 2013 and 2015. I opposed in 2013 and 2015.  Opposing because of past opposition. Not seeing a lot to make me change my past belief. Only 242 edits in the last year means I have to think they aren't much engaged with the project. And lack of answers to many of the questions is a further issue.
 * 13)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/Writ Keeper/Questions 19,315 edits total, 5112 automated, 14,203 manual edits. Account started editing 2011. 10.8% to articles, 2.7% to article talk, 19.2% to user pages, 45.6% to user talk pages, 17.9% to wikipedia space, 3.1% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 3 May. 0 articles with over 100 edits. 614 edits in the last 365 days. 523 edits to ANI, 207 edits to AN. 38 pages created, 32 were redirects, so 6 "real" pages created. Is an admin.
 * 14) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 192 edits
 * 15) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 265 edits
 * 16) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 14 edits
 * 17) Never has run for ArbCom before. I like WK, but I'm not seeing enough engagement with the project here recently. Regretfully oppose.

Neutral

 * 1)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/Calidum/Questions 15,815 edits total, 3648 automated, 12,167 manual edits. Account started editing 2011. 40% to articles, 19.1% to article talk, 2.1% to user pages, 19.6% to user talk pages, 15.3% to wikipedia space, 3.2% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 29 August. 0 articles with over 100 edits. 83 edits to ANI, less than 10 edits to AN. 2205 edits in the last 365 days. 148 pages created, 142 were redirects, so 6 "real" pages created. Is NOT an admin. Never a member of ArbCom.
 * 2) Alternate account:  - Edit tools No edits listed.
 * 3) Alternate account:  - Edit tools No edits listed.
 * 4) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 2 edits listed.
 * 5) Ran in 2011 and 2014. I opposed in 2011 (when they had under 1000 edits) but supported in 2014. I like the thought of a non-admin on the committee but I'm not convinced he's the one. Less impressed with the answers to the questions this year, so going neutral.
 * 6)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/DGG/Questions 214,000 edits total. Account started editing 2003. 33.1% to articles, 5.9% to article talk, 3.6% to user pages, 23.8% to user talk pages, 26.7% to wikipedia space, 4.3% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 6 November. No articles with over 100 edits. 18,180 edits in the last 365 days. 1505 edits to ANI, 626 edits to AN. 2172 pages created, 1927 were redirects, so 245 "real" pages created. Is an admin. Current member of ArbCom.
 * 7) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 1483 edits.
 * 8) Ran in 2014. I supported in 2014. Not greatly impressed with their work on the committee, thus the neutral.
 * 9)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/Euryalus/Questions  30,773 edits total, 2903 automated, 27,870 manual edits. Account started editing 2007. 53.3% to articles, 15.9% to article talk, 2% to user pages, 13.9% to user talk pages, 10.2% to wikipedia space, 1.9% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 25 September. 6 articles with over 100 edits. 3188 edits in the last 365 days. 530 edits to ANI, 112 edits to AN. 202 pages created, 134 were redirects, so 68 "real" pages created. Is an admin. Current member of ArbCom.
 * 10) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 32 edits.
 * 11) Ran in 2014. I was neutral in 2014. Underwhelmed with their work on the committee.
 * 12)  - Edit tools Arbitration Committee Elections December 2016/Candidates/Mkdw/Questions  28,367 edits total, 4551 automated, 23,816 manual edits. Account started editing 2006. 28.7% to articles, 7.2% to article talk, 4.2% to user pages, 26.4% to user talk pages, 22.3% to wikipedia space, 3.6% to wikipedia talk pages. Last 500 edits go back to 30 September. 3172 edits in the last 365 days. 7 articles with over 100 edits. 190 edits to ANI, Under 20 edits to AN. 165 pages created, 92 were redirects, so 73 "real" pages created. Is an admin.-->
 * 13) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 16 edits
 * 14) Alternate account:  - Edit tools 13 edits
 * 15) Never has run for ArbCom before. Read over the questions and answers. Very ... 'meh'. Nothing says I need to vote for this person.